Sum Ting Huang: The 352nd Evolutionary Lens with Bret Weinstein and Heather Heying

Episode number: 352
Episode title: Sum Ting Huang: The 352nd Evolutionary Lens with Bret Weinstein and Heather Heying
Published date: November 17, 2026
Hosts: Bret Weinstein and Heather Heying
Guest: None
Show: The Evolutionary Lens, DarkHorse Podcast
Transcript source: Edited machine transcript with speaker labels; timestamps are from the start of the recording

Video: Watch on YouTube
Rumble: Watch on Rumble
Audio: Listen to the episode

Summary

Bret Weinstein and Heather Heying discuss the Jensen Huang story at Nvidia alongside the Russell Brand case covered the previous week. Bret proposes that each case contains two stories: a human story about behavior that people are wired to watch, and a story about technology, finance, law and governance that the first can obscure. Heather reads and responds to social media commentary blaming Lori Huang's appearance for her husband's infidelity, which leads to a discussion of marriage, aging, polygyny, the "trad" movement, and why young people seem to be falling in love less. The hosts then turn to reporting on consensual non-consent parties connected to Bay Area AI culture, Huang's role in building CUDA and opposing AI chip export restrictions, and the question of why these men, and why now.

Main Topics

  • Jensen Huang, Nvidia, and the human story vs. the governance story

  • Russell Brand as a political prisoner, and the Tate brothers

  • What feminism promised women, and the risks of marriage

  • Young people not falling in love

  • Social media commentary on Lori Huang's appearance

  • Cheating, choice, and a broken culture

  • The math of polygyny

  • Why "trad" isn't traditional

  • Hot vs. beauty, and aging

  • Tech titans, reductionism, and STEM without the science

  • Meghan Murphy: an argument against marriage, or for polygamy?

  • Transhumanism as a mistake

  • Red Means No and consensual non-consent in Silicon Valley

  • "Baby, It's Cold Outside" and consent culture

  • Was Jensen Huang pushed out of Nvidia?

  • CUDA and the "zero-billion-dollar market"

  • AI restrictionists, effective altruism, rationalists, and moats

  • Russell Brand's wife and the UK courts

  • Why them? Why now?

Questions Answered in This Episode

What are the "two stories" Bret Weinstein sees in the Jensen Huang and Russell Brand cases?

[00:15:11] Bret describes a human story that people are wired to process, which sorts everyone into heroes and villains, and a second story about technology, finance and governance. He argues that in the Brand case, behavior that was "very disgusting" and true kept many people from seeing something dangerous unfolding legally. He says neither story is unimportant, and the hosts frame the question at the intersection as "why these men?" The episode states there is no suggestion that Huang's behavior was criminal (00:16:44).

Why does Bret call Russell Brand a political prisoner, and why didn't he defend the Tate brothers?

[00:18:10] Bret repeats his view that Brand is "a political prisoner hiding in plain sight" and notes that Neil Oliver, Robert Malone and Mikki Willis have made similar arguments. He says he did not defend the Tate brothers because what they had said on video reflected what they are being prosecuted for, while adding that he is not a scholar of the legal case in Romania. In Brand's case, he says, that question is not at all clear.

Which matters more, Jensen Huang's affair or his role at Nvidia?

[00:23:17] The hosts disagree here. Bret says the social issue is as important but argues that Huang's real effect is on chip export policy and on how the world approaches the dangers of AI, while his personal behavior is "a drop in the bucket" for the culture. Heather argues (00:20:15, 00:23:56) that the public reaction reveals how people feel about infidelity and helps explain why young people are opting out of relationships.

What does Heather Heying say feminism promised women?

[00:21:42] Heather says that growing up in the 1970s and 80s she saw feminism's promise being realized, but that the promise that marrying a good man and building a family would bring a secure life "until death do you part" is too often a lie, because powerful men often leave the wives they started their lives with for someone younger.

Why does Bret Weinstein say young people aren't falling in love?

[00:27:30] Bret repeats a point from clips of his appearance on the Jack Neel podcast: young people don't seem to be falling in love anymore, which he calls a profound and alarming change, given that falling in love once steered most of human life and most popular songs. He later says (00:29:43) that relations between men and women have become so broken that people may accept sex robots "as a relief."

Does a troubled upbringing excuse cheating?

[00:35:22] Heather says no: cheaters have a choice, and "couldn't" almost always means "wouldn't." She says she is increasingly unwilling to excuse behavior on the grounds of developmental background. Bret (00:37:05) agrees that changing early development is your responsibility, but argues that sexual identity is also shaped in early adulthood by a broken culture, and that young people are rarely told what that culture is taking from them.

What happens to men, women and children under polygyny?

[00:49:46] Heather describes a classroom exercise from her years teaching animal behavior: many men initially think polygyny sounds appealing until she shows the math. With a roughly even sex ratio, a few men monopolize many women and leave other men with no partners, who then become angry. Bret adds that it is a disaster for most men and bad but not intolerable for women if only resources count, and Heather says it is worst for children. She argues it only works on a purely transactional view of relationships.

Why don't Bret and Heather think "trad" works?

[00:54:16] Heather says the modern trad lifestyle carries too much risk and leaves too much on the table for women, and that it forgets that in agrarian life men and women both worked inside their own property lines. Bret says trad "isn't traditional masquerading as traditional," and that apart from groups like the Amish, no one has a long-standing culture to simply pass on.

What is the difference between "hot" and beauty?

[00:58:06] Bret says the culture has fetishized hot, which fades with age, and fails to recognize beauty, which doesn't. He describes hot as tied to men looking to reproduce without commitment. He says spouses owe it to each other to age as gracefully as they can, but that current expectations come from a superficial, consumption-oriented culture.

Why do brilliant tech billionaires fail at relationships?

[01:05:56] Bret suggests that masters of the extremely complicated may have extreme failure modes when it comes to the complex. Heather says they are trying to "spreadsheet the world" using tech, engineering and math without the science, and that while that may work for rockets, it doesn't work for relationships.

Why does Bret Weinstein say transhumanism is a mistake?

[01:14:18] Bret argues that people with complicated-level understanding believe they can upgrade complex systems they don't understand. In a complicated domain like computing, the newest model is usually best; in a complex one, any significant change brings costs you didn't anticipate. He says human reproduction, and the dual inheritance of genes and culture, is too fundamental to upend.

What is Red Means No, and what do Bret and Heather say about it?

[01:15:51] Bret describes Washington Free Beacon reporting that an AI researcher at Anthropic runs a business hosting consensual non-consent parties in the Bay Area. Bret reads the report: filings reviewed by the Free Beacon apparently show sexual assault allegations, and some women reported feeling pressured to attend to advance their careers. Bret says he is not claiming any laws were broken and that his concern is the culture. He argues it normalizes rape (01:21:56) and that its prominence in the culture of AI companies is alarming.

Why does Bret think Jensen Huang matters to Nvidia's success?

[01:25:38] Bret describes CUDA, which he says Huang championed in 2006: building Nvidia's graphics cards to handle non-graphical parallel computation before any market existed. He says the bet was costly until the AI boom, and that Huang called it a "zero-billion-dollar market." Bret says the story appears to be true and shows both business and engineering skill.

Was Jensen Huang pushed out of Nvidia?

[01:24:04] Bret notes it has been alleged that Huang's exit was effectively a coup, and says the evidence that the woman involved was a spy "isn't so great, but maybe." He argues (01:30:10) that Huang stood out for opposing AI restrictionists, including effective altruists, rationalists and companies seeking a regulatory moat, and for fighting AI chip export restrictions. He offers this as a reason a coup is possible, not as an established fact.

Why them, and why now?

[01:36:51] Bret argues that because many billionaires behave badly, scandal can be used selectively against those who stand in the way of a desired policy, and that this is hidden by a human story people can't look away from. He also says the UK courts' reported pursuit of Russell Brand's wife for delivering his message confirms the hosts' concerns about that case. Heather (01:38:03) asks viewers, when a story grabs them, to ask why that story, why those men, and why now.

Search Keywords

Bret Weinstein, Heather Heying, DarkHorse Podcast, The Evolutionary Lens, Jensen Huang, Lori Huang, Nvidia, Russell Brand, Andrew Tate, infidelity, marriage, monogamy, polygyny, polygamy, feminism, aging, trad, Meghan Murphy, Red Means No, consensual non-consent, Anthropic, OpenAI, Washington Free Beacon, Wall Street Journal, CUDA, AI export restrictions, effective altruism, rationalists, Eliezer Yudkowsky, Alexandros Marinos, Elon Musk, transhumanism, why now

Chapters

00:00:00 Life in a Cartesian Crisis
00:03:32 Sponsor: Ridge
00:05:42 When Did Milliamp Mean Anything?
00:07:42 Sponsor: Caraway
00:09:39 Sponsor: CrowdHealth
00:11:23 The Huangs of Nvidia
00:18:10 Russell Brand vs. the Tate Brothers
00:20:58 The Promise of Feminism
00:27:13 Young People Aren't Falling in Love
00:31:32 Twitter Takes: Blame the Wife
00:35:23 Couldn't Help It? Nah.
00:44:41 She Did Not Marry a Billionaire
00:49:46 The Math of Polygyny
00:54:13 Trad Isn't Traditional
00:56:38 Hot vs. Beauty
01:03:13 Rockets Yes, Relationships No
01:07:45 Allowed to Look 65
01:10:17 Against Marriage or for Polygamy?
01:15:51 Silicon Valley's Red Means No
01:23:52 Was It a Coup at Nvidia?
01:25:38 CUDA: The Zero-Billion-Dollar Market
01:30:22 Doomers, Moats, and Export Controls
01:38:03 Why Them? Why Now?
01:40:17 See You the Day Before Thanksgiving

Mentioned in This Episode

Our Sponsors

Ridge: Upgrade your wallet today! Get 10% off @Ridge with code DARKHORSE at https://www.Ridge.com/darkhorse #Ridgepod

Caraway: Non-toxic, highly functional & beautiful cookware and bakeware. Save up to $230 on their 12 piece cookware set, explore more set savings on bakeware, storage and accessories, and visit Carawayhome.com/DHPOD for an additional 10% off your next purchase.

CrowdHealth: Pay for healthcare with crowdfunding instead of insurance. It’s way better. Use code DarkHorse at http://JoinCrowdHealth.com to get 1st 3 months for $99/month.

Join Us

Join us on Locals! Get access to our Discord server, exclusive live streams, live chats for all streams, and early access to many podcasts: https://darkhorse.locals.com

Heather’s newsletter, Natural Selections (subscribe to get free weekly essays in your inbox): https://naturalselections.substack.com

Our book, A Hunter-Gatherer’s Guide to the 21st Century, is available everywhere books are sold, including from Amazon: https://amzn.to/3AGANGg (commission earned)

DarkHorse Store: https://darkhorsestore.org

Transcript

[00:00:07] Bret Weinstein: Hey folks, welcome to the 352nd DarkHorse Podcast livestream. I'm Dr. Bret Weinstein. You are Dr. Heather Heying. It is late November.

[00:00:21] Heather Heying: I could not have imagined six and a half years ago still doing this.

[00:00:27] Bret Weinstein: Yeah, things are strange. Let's put it this way. If you're watching it, you are not suffering from one of the amazing number of outages that seem to be striking everything, including, oddly enough, the NSA.

[00:00:42] Heather Heying: Oh, okay. I don't know if it didn't work.

[00:00:45] Bret Weinstein: I don't know if we're safer or less safe with the NSA down. I just, it's a hard call.

[00:00:49] Heather Heying: Such is the nature of life in a Cartesian crisis.

[00:00:52] Bret Weinstein: Yes. So exactly. Yeah. Which way is up?

[00:00:55] Heather Heying: Which way is up? So yeah, last week we talked about Russell Brand. We're going to talk about a different kind of sexual behavior that's in the news and what brings them together. How it is that we view these events, Russell Brand last week, Jensen Huang at Nvidia this week, in simultaneously a totally dissimilar and a similar light. And how and why, what it means.

[00:01:29] Bret Weinstein: Yes. A strange reddish light that is now shining on all sorts of things and civilization seems to be dependent on how we navigate through. But anyway, it'll be an interesting discussion for sure.

[00:01:43] Heather Heying: I think so. I hope so. So check us out on Locals. That's where we've got our live stream, our watch party going on. And we also still have our selling books for another week or two, all sold out of the English language version of Hunter- Gatherer's Guide to the 21st Century, which is our co-authored book that came out in 2021. But we still have a couple or few or just one copy left of the Brazilian Portuguese, Polish, French, Spanish and Thai versions. If any of those suit your fancy or if you've been looking to learn a new language. And we also have lots of copies of my first book, Antipode: Seasons with the Extraordinary Wildlife and Culture of Madagascar, about my life and research in Madagascar, which is where I did my dissertation research on, of course, the sex lives of poison frogs in Madagascar, which is why I am such the authority that you should listen to on the sex lives of poison CEOs and lad culture.

[00:02:49] Bret Weinstein: Colorful CEOs and their crazy sex lives. Yes. Yes.

[00:02:53] Heather Heying: So you can find those books at our, not dumb, website, darkhorsepodcast.org slash books, and we'll sign them for you, personalize them if you want, and, and get those sent out in time for the holidays, not any holidays, depending on what holidays you celebrate if they're coming, you know, up in the next week or two, probably not, but they'll be out to you by the usually celebrated holidays in the middle to end of December.

[00:03:22] Bret Weinstein: There it is.

[00:03:23] Heather Heying: There it is. All right. Sponsors carefully chosen three at the top of the hour, as usual, you are up first.

[00:03:32] Bret Weinstein: I don't know that it's usual that I'm up first, but our first sponsor this week is Ridge. And if you don't already have a Ridge wallet, you should. It's slim. It's modern RFID blocking and built to last. It is the last wallet you'll ever buy. I certainly use the heck out of mine. Great for traveling. Keep your passport card on the little strap on the back. Anyway, it's wonderful. But now there's also Ridge's five in one travel power bank, which is right here. Actually, it's not right here because I am actively using it and forgot to pull it off the charger on the wall. I use it every night. It frees me from having cords plugged into my phone. It's really awesome. It will change the way you travel for sure.

[00:04:18] Heather Heying: But it's not actually transparent.

[00:04:20] Bret Weinstein: No,

[00:04:21] Heather Heying: this is not like Wonder Woman's plane.

[00:04:23] Bret Weinstein: This maybe they make a transparent one. Mine is black. It works great. It has a little screen to tell you how much charge has left. It uses the MagSafe, which is a wonderful addition. And it has lightning and USB-C if you want to plug in with cables. So it lets you charge all your devices at the same time. It's got my... Oh, I already said that. Magnets directly onto the back of your phone so you can charge without any wires. And that is my preference. Ridge's power bank is powerful at 20 watts, charging your phone fast. It's high capacity. 10,000 milliamp hours provides up to three full phone charges. There's an LED display that tells you your charge level at a glance and an integrated kickstand too. And it is available in matte black, matte olive, and Basecamp orange, but sadly not transparent. As with all Ridge products, you get free shipping and a 99-day risk-free trial and a lifetime warranty. One thing to pack, five ways to power.

[00:05:21] Bret Weinstein: You can find Ridge's power bank at Best Buy or our listeners can get 10% off at ridge.com by using the code DARKHORSE at checkout. Just head to ridge.com and use the code DARKHORSE and you're all set. After you purchase, they will ask you where you heard about them. Now, what do you think I'm going to tell you? Tell them DarkHorse sent. Yeah.

[00:05:42] Heather Heying: For some reason that read prompted me to think we talk a lot about how sometimes sentences or whole paragraphs that we'll utter to one another would have been completely inexplicable and uninterpretable. Sometimes 10 years ago, but more often we refer to ourselves in high school, right? And there were a few words in that read power bank, for instance, that wouldn't have made a lot of sense back in the 80s, but you probably could have gotten there. You could have understood what was being alluded to, even if you didn't know exactly what was going on. But it made me wonder about words that have meant something to all of us who've thought about these concepts since we were born. But when was the moment when, for instance, the word milliamp would have been uninterpretable, but it was shortly before presumably amp, like milli is an old prefix. But when does amp show up enough for people that you could say something like milliamp and have it be at least somewhat meaningful for people?

[00:06:50] Bret Weinstein: I think milliamps and milliamp hours were already a thing when you and I showed up on this planet. But they're obviously.

[00:06:59] Heather Heying: No, I think so, too. I think it's way older. This is my point. I think certainly amps, way older than the rest of the stuff we're talking about. This is my point. There are a number of concepts that we just take for granted now. But there was a moment shortly before they showed up on the scene when if you said to someone, they could be like, well, I don't know. Maybe I can begin to figure out what that might mean. But it hasn't like the thing either hasn't been invented yet, but the time is ripe. Like everything is in place and the person who puts them together hasn't showed up yet. But but therefore the term could be perhaps understood under the right circumstances.

[00:07:38] Bret Weinstein: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You could get there from wherever you were.

[00:07:42] Heather Heying: Our second sponsor this week is Caraway, which is an old concept because it's an old plant. But that is not the kind of caraway we're talking about. Caraway, the company, makes high quality non-toxic cookware and bakeware. Whether you're spending time at the grill, the stove or the oven, Caraway has the gear for you. Prepare a savory roast in Caraway's cookware, bake an apple or pumpkin pie in their bakeware or make autumn inspired craft cocktails with their bar set. Having functional cookware, bakeware and other kitchen essentials in your kitchen, which are also beautiful, is awesome no matter the season. Caraway has everything from mixing bowl sets and cutting boards to muffin tins and big pots in which to braise a piece of meat or make a long-simmered stew. Caraway kitchenware is crafted with FSC certified birch wood, premium stainless steel, enamel cast iron and naturally slick ceramic. They make several lines of cookware and bakeware, our favorites their stainless steel line and their enamel cast iron, which is offered in six stylish and beautiful colors.

[00:08:35] Heather Heying: These pots are strong and highly scratch resistant. They'll last generations. And Caraway just launched their new 10 cup coffee maker. Unlike the plastic used in most traditional machines, Caraway's coffee maker uses glass and seamless steel in the parts of the brewer that touch hot water and coffee. And it has a one button dial which helps simplify busy morning routines. We're cooking with Caraway as is our son Zach. It's great stuff and they keep adding products whether you're looking for cake pans or steamers, ways to organize your lids, or store your leftovers, Caraway's got it. Reset your kitchen on a budget. Bundle and save up to $230 on the 12 piece cookware set versus buying the products individually. Explore more set savings on bakeware, food storage, accessories and more. Visit carawayhome.com slash dhpod to take an additional 10% off your next purchase. This deal is exclusive for our listeners. So visit carawayhome.com slash dhpod or use code DHPOD at checkout.

[00:09:27] Bret Weinstein: Eggs not included.

[00:09:29] Heather Heying: Eggs are not included nor is that big delicious, braisable hunk of meat.

[00:09:33] Bret Weinstein: No, you're gonna have to source that.

[00:09:35] Heather Heying: Yeah, you will.

[00:09:36] Bret Weinstein: Locally is best.

[00:09:37] Heather Heying: Indeed. Our final sponsor this week is CrowdHealth. CrowdHealth is not health insurance, it's better. CrowdHealth is a community of people helping to decentralize healthcare costs from funding medical costs to help negotiate your bills. We've had it for several years now instead of insurance and have had occasion to use it a few times. Each time the CrowdHealth community has helped fund the hospital bills with a simple straightforward app. And we have interacted with people who are easy to reach and helpful. If you're in the United States, you know that health insurance here is a mess, complicated, hostile and expensive. We used to contend with this madness, but not anymore. There is a better way. You too can stop playing the rigged insurance game. CrowdHealth is a community of people funding each other's medical bills directly. No middlemen, no insurance, no nonsense. With CrowdHealth, you get health care for under $100 per month for your first three months, including access to a team of health bill negotiators, low cost prescription and lab testing tools, a database of low cost, high quality doctors, vetted by CrowdHealth.

[00:10:32] Heather Heying: You pay for little stuff out of pocket. But for any event that costs more than $500, like a diagnosis that requires ongoing treatment or a pregnancy or an accident, you pay the first $500 and the crowd pays the rest. It's straightforward, affordable and much better than health insurance. The health insurance system is hoping you'll stay stuck in their same overpriced, over complicated mess. Don't do it. Take charge of your health expenses and be part of a community. Join CrowdHealth to get started today for $99 a month for your first three months using code DarkHorse at JoinCrowdHealth.com. That's JoinCrowdHealth.com, code DarkHorse. And remember, CrowdHealth is not insurance. Opt out. Take your power back. This is how we win. JoinCrowdHealth.com.

[00:11:13] Bret Weinstein: So much better. So much better. So much better. All right. It's time.

[00:11:21] Heather Heying: It's time.

[00:11:22] Bret Weinstein: Yeah. So we're going to be talking about the Jensen Huang story at Nvidia. We're going to pronounce both of those things that way throughout the podcast.

[00:11:33] Heather Heying: We're going to try. Yeah. And anyone who wants to pronounce it differently, be our guest.

[00:11:36] Bret Weinstein: Yeah. That's that's on you, really. But in any case, I'm not sure how we could start this. Do you want to describe this equation as we find it?

[00:11:46] Heather Heying: I'm not sure that I do. I will say that one thing I want to do is I just pulled a bunch of screenshots from Twitter to show sort of what some of the discourse sounds like specifically with regard to the infidelity, not with regard to the effects both in AI and globally and economically and financially. Of the repercussions of the blowout of Nvidia just having lost their CEO. But we'll talk about that, too. And in fact, I think that is the more important thing. But at some point, I do want to at some point earlier, I want to just show us show our audience some of what many people already have seen. And we've both seen the discussion around around what happened at the point that Jensen Huang was discovered to have had not one, not two, but apparently three or more affairs. Thus being revealed to have been having cheated on his wife of 40 plus years, a woman whom he met when they were both engineering students freshman, I believe both at Oregon State.

[00:12:58] Bret Weinstein: Yep.

[00:13:00] Heather Heying: They've both ended up with degrees in electrical engineering. I think at least she has a degree in electrical engineering. Maybe this is a mechanical, maybe they're both electrical, I don't know.

[00:13:08] Bret Weinstein: But they are both electrical. At least he is an electrical engineer. Yeah. that. Okay.

[00:13:12] Heather Heying: And he then, you know, went on to found as he apparently promised her when they first met when he was wooing her she two years his senior I think they met when she was 19 and he was 17. He promised her then or said to her then or you know, asserted then that he would be a CEO before 30. And it turns out that he was right. He was driven. He was skilled. And she also very skilled in in what in her chosen field. But she opted to step away from engineering at the point that they were having a family. And so she has spent a considerable amount of her time in the ensuing years raising their children and and also running philanthropic organization. And I gather also being part of Nvidia as well, although there's a lot about exactly what is true of her and her role and various things that is not clear.

[00:14:12] Bret Weinstein: Yep, I will just add, believe they have two children. Yes, I believe both those children now work at Nvidia.

[00:14:19] Heather Heying: Both of those children work at Nvidia as does the husband of the daughter. So Madison, the daughter was I guess did was trained as like a chef, maybe. And then not too many years ago stepped into a role at Nvidia and quickly became very important there. Her husband is some kind of VP. And I believe the brother the son of Jensen and Lori is doing engineering work. I may be wrong about that. But yes, it's it's a it's a giant, obviously, corporation that became more powerful than Apple through a sort of a twist of fate. And it is also you know, it it employs thousands, but it is also at some level a family, a family outfit or it was until these last couple of weeks.

[00:15:11] Bret Weinstein: So I want to just suggest a framework. There are two stories here. And I think we've learned from feedback on the Russell Brand story, that there is a trap that we shouldn't fall into, and our viewers shouldn't fall into. And the trap is you have a human story that we humans are wired to process. And it creates our sense of who's a villain, who's a hero, all of that stuff. And it is very important to step back from that and to understand issues of technology, finance, governance, all of those other questions. And, you know, as with the case of Russell Brand, you had very disgusting behavior that was unarguably true. And that caused a lot of people not to be able to see that there was something dangerous unfolding legally, and that maybe in fact, the disgusting behavior was being used to normalize the abuse of the legal system, etc. So I think we need to track these two stories, I think, and I don't think either of them is unimportant.

[00:16:30] Bret Weinstein: You've got a human story that's very important, because it has a lot to do with how civilization is functioning. And you have a human and governance story, which is very important, because humanity is in some sense depending on how this all turns out.

[00:16:44] Heather Heying: And you have the question, therefore, in the intersection between these two stories, about why these men. I believe that in both of these cases, these men involved in these men were involved in disgusting behavior, disgusting in totally different ways. And we talked last week about whether or not disgusting behavior in question was criminal or not. And there is no suggestion that the behavior that Jensen Huang has engaged in is criminal. But disgusting, for sure. Lots of people engage in disgusting behavior. Many, many people do. There is no excuse for it. I wish that none of it happened. But why these men? So that is the question at the interface between the stories that I think that we'll arrive at later. Just as you said last week, this feels it feels like Russell Brand is effectively a political prisoner. And you could say that without in any way excusing the reprehensible and disgusting behavior. And because at the same time that he is being beyond pilloried, but imprisoned for a period of time that seems extraordinary, especially in comparison with what people are getting away with all the time.

[00:18:02] Heather Heying: Why him? Why that sentence? Why now? And we might ask the same question about Jensen Huang.

[00:18:10] Bret Weinstein: Yeah. If I can just point out an interesting pattern that may help people see this. I said Russell Brand is a political prisoner hiding in plain sight. I have now seen Neil Oliver say something similar. I have seen Robert Malone say something similar. Mikki Willis has put out a documentary explaining what the position is, why this is such a troubling conviction. Those are all all four of us are men with good marriages to which we are deeply committed defending a guy who behaved in ways that I don't think any of us would entertain behaving in. Is that because we're hypocrites and inconsistent? No. And I will just speak for myself here. Let me say, I did not defend the Tate brothers. Why not? I didn't defend the Tate brothers because when I went and looked at what they had said, it reflected exactly the things that they're being prosecuted for. Now, I'm not a scholar. I don't understand the international legal ramifications. I don't understand what's going on in Romania.

[00:19:24] Bret Weinstein: I can't speak to any of that. But the question of whether or not these people had behaved in exactly the way that they were being portrayed in court seemed to be clear based on lots of things that were said on video. And I believe it not to be at all clear in the case of Russell Brand. So again, the stories, the story divides on whether or not you can separate the personal conduct from the larger questions, which obviously have at least more direct effects on us, even if the cultural issues have effects on us. Those are diffuse. Whereas, you know, the fate of AI chip exports has an implication for us, an important implication.

[00:20:15] Heather Heying: Well, okay. I'm going to take an issue with that. I would say that obviously AI chip import ultimately does have broad implications for us. But the conversation that is emerging, that is revealing what some portion of society feels about infidelity and cheating. And also with regard to the Russell Brand case about promiscuity and celebrity culture, actually says a lot about, and I know, Yemi, you've been speaking about this publicly, says a lot about why I think young people are increasingly just saying, I'm just not doing it. I'm not going there. And so, you know, I can only speak as a woman, obviously. And I hate the framing as a woman, but I think it's highly relevant here because, you know, unlike questions of, say, race, where we're all still human and you have had different lived experiences than I have for sure, but regardless of your skin color, you are fundamentally human and we can assume some commonality of experience. Men and women from at least from the moment they hit puberty, and in every culture that I know from before then due to enculturization, have different experiences of the world.

[00:21:42] Heather Heying: And I will say that to me, growing up in the 70s and 80s, the promise of feminism, which until recently I was still defending as a word, and I think I've given up on the word at this point, but the promise of feminism was being realized then, and had it made mistakes and had it overpromised and had it not seen the hidden costs of some of what it was advocating for, sure. But it was recognizing that there are costs and traps in all of the ways that we can choose to behave, and that the promise that if you simply sign on with a good man and choose to pursue your passions for doing good in the world in whatever way you can while also creating a family with him, that you will have a good and secure and wonderful life until death do you part, is too often a lie. That men often, hopefully not frequently, but often we know this, especially men who become powerful later in life, which is when men become powerful, too often throw over the wives with whom they had their children and with whom they started their lives, and for whom those wives gave up what they could have been for someone younger who's hotter, who's available now, when maybe they couldn't have had anything like that when they were younger.

[00:23:17] Bret Weinstein: All right, I want to add something though. I'm not arguing that the social issue is in the end less important. I think it's as important. What I'm arguing is that Jensen Huang has a real effect on chip export policy and our posture towards the dangers of AI, whereas his behavior is a drop in the bucket that does not affect the culture profoundly. It affects a little bit because in this case he's modeling a behavior, but his effect on the way people treat each other is small. His effect on the technological issues is profound.

[00:23:56] Heather Heying: Well, I think what we see on social media in the wake of this reveals how much justification people are giving to their basest feelings. I will say one of the things that I've been reckoning with before I show some of these screenshots is my reaction to the Russell Brand case, as we spoke to for a long time last week, so I won't re-explain all of it here, but my reaction to it was, "That's disgusting, and that's reprehensible," and everyone involved there was playing a game, and the stakes were high, and it was risky, and it was gross, and there's no excuse for rape, but they were all playing a game, and it wasn't a good game. No one should have been playing that game. In this case, you have people who got together young and made oaths to one another, and promised loyalty, and promised fidelity, and you know, who knows? Who knows what actually went inside that marriage? Maybe it's going to be revealed that she said yes to everything.

[00:25:04] Heather Heying: I doubt it. The problem for women is that third-wave feminism embraced the lad culture stuff with the risky, gross, promiscuous game in which men get to be--women get to behave as stupidly as men at their worst. And part of the promise of feminism that I heard when I was growing up was, actually, you can, frankly, have it all. You can choose to be in a loyal and loving and amazing relationship, and have and raise extraordinary children with your partner, and also pursue the professional passions that you're interested in doing. Like, you can actually do that, and indeed, one of the things that I had in my head growing up was, I don't know how any woman thinks it's safe not to. I can't fathom why women imagine that the men whom they adore at this moment and love and are raising children with are 100% guaranteed to stick around if things change. So that is a tension that much is not reckoning with. The idea that--I mean, just like a woman who says, "I don't want to sign a prenup," that's what it's called, right?

[00:26:36] Heather Heying: A prenuptial, because this is going to be forever, right? Is maybe being a little naive, and if she is saying, "I'm going to give up on everything that might allow me to be independent if things go south," she's being a little naive. And that doesn't mean that she doesn't completely love and is hopeful that this is going to be everything. Presumably, everyone, everyone who's signing on to marriage hopes and assumes that it's forever.

[00:27:13] Bret Weinstein: Well, I gotta tell you, I'm having a weird week because of the clips-- Well, sure, we are all having a weird week, but some of the clips that were released from the Jack Neel podcast seem to have caught people's attention.

[00:27:29] Heather Heying: You want to say something about what--

[00:27:30] Bret Weinstein: Yeah, effectively, and one of them, I think our audience has heard me say this, but my contention was that young people don't seem to be falling in love anymore, and that that's actually an utterly profound transition, that it used to be that nine out of 10 songs were about falling in love, that the world was steered by this very powerful biological force that overtook you, and the fact that it doesn't seem to be happening with young people anymore is truly alarming, should be. This is a very fundamental human thing. So anyway, point is, having said that and having watched it actually spread over borders and into audiences who don't have any idea who I might be or whatever, I'm getting a lot of interesting feedback. So I'm not sure that part of what's going on here is that you've got a kind of legacy problem. We've got a much bigger problem, which is that none of this stuff is working at all, and that dealing with the boomers and the dysfunction in their relationships is like just the most mild preview of the dysfunction that is coming.

[00:28:46] Heather Heying: Well, and separately, actually, now in the last couple of weeks, I don't know if you've been seeing it, but there's this discourse around millennial parents who are reporting that their grandparents have never even met their kids, don't have any interest in the grandchildren. So there's just this illusion of family and relationship across the board. But with regard to young people, to looking at the landscape and going, "Do I want promiscuous, disgusting culture where I might be inclined to lick a dude's asshole within minutes of meeting him, or do I sign up for someone whom I actually really love and make children with him and create a family and then maybe be overthrown and be mocked widely on the internet later on?" I think that second risk is still the better one, but don't pretend it's not a risk. Don't pretend that if those are the two choices available to women, that this is not a good situation.

[00:29:43] Bret Weinstein: Oh, it is absolutely a disaster, and we're in freefall because the way men and women are now showing up in each other's lives is so broken that effectively people are going to accept the sex robots as a relief, because at least they don't have the defects of a flesh and blood human of the opposite sex. And we are not getting out of this. There is no way you can dehumanize us and recover a meaningful, functional culture that accomplishes things, and we can come back to that later. Before you go further, I don't know if this is the right place, but I do want to talk about what Huang is relative to Nvidia. It's not... I know a little bit about the story about how Nvidia became the giant that it is, the powerhouse, but I hadn't understood Huang's specific contribution to it until I started digging, and it's important in this story.

[00:30:48] Heather Heying: Okay.

[00:30:48] Bret Weinstein: Let's go here.

[00:30:49] Heather Heying: No, but if you want to do it, you can't.

[00:30:51] Bret Weinstein: No, let's save that.

[00:30:52] Heather Heying: I feel like we've got two very different stories, right? Yeah. So let's save that to open up the second part of the story, because the interpersonal, the disloyalty, the infidelity, has nothing to do with his particular contributions, except that having become extremely powerful and rich and famous within his circles, he suddenly had sexual options that he hadn't had in his youth, presumably. That's the thing that happened to him, because there's a whole lot of talk about what a silver fox he is, and I look at him like, "Nope. He's rich and powerful, guys. That's it." Right? Okay, so let's just go through some of these... just a scattering of screenshots from Twitter this week. An account called Beaver says, "I blame Jensen's wife. You have one job as a billionaire's wife, and it's to be pretty, so he doesn't cheat." Good one, Beaver. To which one person, Jennifer Greenberg, says, "Every abused or betrayed woman knows this lie and it's straight from hell. If you'd lost weight, been a better cook, kept the house cleaner, had more sex, blah, blah, blah.

[00:32:05] Heather Heying: The truth is, abusers abuse, cheaters cheat, it's who they are. Their sin is not your fault." It's an interesting take. There's a part of me that's like, "Yes!" And a part of me also, like, "Well, I think cheaters do cheat." Yep. But there's also two people involved in a relationship that breaks apart.

[00:32:24] Bret Weinstein: Yeah, I think that that one needs a little bit of a rebuttal. It's just, it's too simple.

[00:32:30] Heather Heying: Yeah, it's too simple. Yeah. And so I've got, I don't know, 12 or 14 of these. Yeah. One that you want to... anyone that you want to speak to.

[00:32:37] Bret Weinstein: Well, okay. If we're going to do it in line here, then I would just say the problem... the problem is this. I don't think that any of us, short of maybe some people in religious communities and conservative religious communities at that, I don't think almost any of us have taken on a cultural mythology of marriage that is useful enough to operationalize. I know that I personally feel like I now understand how marriage is supposed to work, but that is having been handed garbage in terms of a description of how it is supposed to work. So my point here would be, I think there is actually a relatively simple story about what makes a marriage work and everything else is some failure mode. And that having not, not having that on the table as a like, "Here's the objective and here's how you should think about it in order to reach that objective," not having that on the table. I think a lot of people fail at this who are not inherently a bad match for each other, who could accomplish it if they knew there was a goal to approach.

[00:33:55] Bret Weinstein: So anyway, I just think the simple formulation is off.

[00:34:00] Heather Heying: I think I agree with that, but I also think that I see in a lot of the, presumably largely non-human accounts, but the gross sort of speaking for young men accounts, like the Beaver one that Jennifer is responding to, are acting, are revealing that they're cheaters, that they would be if they could be, right? That if they ended up in this situation, they clearly would. And that does tell us something about who these characters are and also what is becoming normalized.

[00:34:36] Bret Weinstein: Yeah, but I mean, I'm more embedded in these conversations than I would like, because I get a lot of pushback from, you know, young men who hear me talking about what's possible and they're like,

[00:34:49] Heather Heying: I don't meet those women. There's no one.

[00:34:50] Bret Weinstein: You're full of shit, right? So anyway, I'm more embedded in these conversations than I want, but what I do think is that effectively your developmental trajectory through your early adulthood wrecks the circuitry that you're depending on. And so the point is, I think a lot of these people, as you find them posting, if they even are people, are, yes, they are telling you exactly who they are, but I don't think it was who they had to be. I think.

[00:35:22] Heather Heying: Okay. And so, and the place where you and I are going to disagree a little bit is, I increasingly, I think I always did, simply don't buy the, that's who I am. I can't do anything about it. I am like, cheaters going to cheat, abusers going to abuse. Like, I believe that cheaters tend to cheat and that they have choice and that everyone has choice and that couldn't is almost always an excuse. Wouldn't, didn't, didn't want to, won't, that's what actually usually couldn't means. Couldn't help it. Nah, you could have.

[00:36:02] Bret Weinstein: I'm surprised you think we would disagree about that. Because I think.

[00:36:06] Heather Heying: Oh, no, just I, like I, the place that I think we disagree a little bit is, I'm increasingly just not prepared to give people an excuse for their developmental backgrounds. Like, like I get that lots of people have much more, you know, have, have troubled backgrounds that I cannot begin to fathom because I don't have one because I grew up in a remarkable household that, you know, had its issues for sure. But that was full of love and agency and freedom and respect and loyalty and just, you know, all of the good things. I had so much modeled well for me. That is hard for me to, to really know. And so there will be those who will say, you don't get to say what I can or cannot do. I am this broken. And I think, I think I just increasingly rejected like, yep, I get it. You're, you got, you got harmed. There's damage there, but you still get to choose your behavior is still your own.

[00:37:05] Bret Weinstein: I'm still surprised you think we disagree because maybe the problem is I haven't been clear about categories. There's your early development stuff happens. That stuff's difficult to change, but it is on you to change it. Then there's your early adult development in which stuff gets reinforced on a channel that wasn't especially active when you're a kid. Okay. That stuff forms your sexual identity and it is downstream of very broken culture. So I think the thing that pisses me off is that I didn't have somebody say, actually, your culture is screwing this up. It's robbing you. And there is actually a problem to be solved and solution looks like this, right? So knowing what it is that you're navigating, you know, it's like you head out into the sea. Do you know if there's an Island that you're looking for? Do you have some idea what it, you know, it's, you know, what latitude it might be at so that you know how to pursue it? Or are you like, well, maybe there's something out here or I've, I'm told there's nothing out here.

[00:38:13] Bret Weinstein: So anyway, I'm not.

[00:38:16] Heather Heying: I mean, I think historically, people looked to their own parents and the other parents in their community at church or at school or the ball games or, you know, wherever their community was, that's, that's, that's how people learned what was possible.

[00:38:30] Bret Weinstein: Correct. But that's kind of my point is I think the entire generation of adults was screwed up. They were all broken. And because they were all broken, we all got the message that actually, you know, I'm trying to remember the lyric from the Leonard Cohen song. Anyway, I'll come up with it in a second, but we all got the message that marriage was this cold and broken hallelujah, right?

[00:39:03] Heather Heying: You know, I didn't. And I mean, I, this is not, I didn't expect really to talk about, you know, my natal home here, but I will say, and you know, my father's dead, but my mother's is still alive. And I hope I'm not giving away any family state secrets here. But my parents loved each other so deeply. And I knew from a relatively young age that in neither of their cases was it their first marriage, which was kind of unusual. They were married in 1968. I was born in 1969. I have a sister, half sister from my father's first marriage. And the fact that he left his first wife and his first child caused a rift for him in his church. He was Catholic. And with his family, obviously, with my sister and her mother, but with his natal family. And, you know, but for that decision of his, which was, you know, viewed as unconscionable, I wouldn't be here. And so I can't be anything but grateful that he followed his heart at the point that he met my mother and fell in love with her and said, I'm, you know, I will take care of you, but you're no longer my family.

[00:40:25] Heather Heying: I'm going to make my family with this woman whom I now love. And my mother also had been married before, unless she had no other children. So in the 60s, again, that was somewhat unusual. And I grew up knowing this history. You know, I knew my sister, you know, we didn't spend a lot of time together, but, you know, over holidays and some family trips and such. But I think that probably informed me, like, I love both of my parents fiercely and completely. And my father was a computer engineer and worked long hours. And, you know, almost always made it home for dinner. And my mother made home cooked meals. And it was all of that good, good stuff. And for a little while, when I was in, I want to say, like, late elementary school, for some number of years, she and her best friend had a business together, a calligraphy school and store, because they were both calligraphers. And I remember thinking, and maybe I even said it to her, good, like, this is, this, this is what protects you.

[00:41:30] Heather Heying: Again, I loved my father completely. I could not imagine that he would abandon us. But I knew that it felt unsafe. The amazing life that my mother created for my brother and me, wherein whenever, when we came home from school, she was there. And she took us to our, you know, my piano lessons and our tennis lessons and gymnastics and, you know, all the other swimming lessons and all the other things. And she was there and she was cooking meals and she was making our breakfast in the morning. Also felt to me like it was risky. And that it, it's clearly true.

[00:42:10] Bret Weinstein: So I guess I don't understand why you're disagreeing with me. I'm arguing that that whole generation, even the success stories, all have an incredible degree of brokenness to them. And that that model is part of the problem.

[00:42:25] Heather Heying: What model?

[00:42:26] Bret Weinstein: The model. This is what marriage is. And I think they were just misleading. I mean, I saw my maternal grandparents had a marriage that looked very functional, but my grandmother died when I was 13. I didn't see it through adult eyes. I saw something, but, you know, my sense is that Silents and Boomers on down, things were very screwed up. I can't really speak to the older generations because all we have is really the mythology of who they were. We didn't see them as adults. And so all I'm saying is our culture has a problem because our culture has a problem. We are watching people just like with the orthodontist story or what I'm sure will be the story for, you know, eyesight and nutrition and all of these things. We're watching something that has been modernized and is now maiming each new generation. And I'm just claiming that one of the things that is maiming each new generation is bad mythology that frankly is getting worse with every generation.

[00:43:36] Bret Weinstein: And so anyway, I think I think the way we got here was that I'm just simply suggesting that the the Huangs and their problem is a version that belongs to a generation that is not a mirror of the brokenness of the active culture at the moment. It's a holdover. It's a brokenness to be sure, a radical one, but that we're looking at a state of dysfunction that's actually twice as bad now.

[00:44:12] Heather Heying: But different in flavor. Okay, let's look at a little bit of the other things that X delivered up to us this week on the Jensen Huang affair.

[00:44:27] Bret Weinstein: I will say he has admitted to one. I don't think he's admitted to the other two. I don't know. Everybody assumes that they're real, but yeah, I don't know.

[00:44:41] Heather Heying: Okay, so again, responding, still responding to this Beaver account saying, I blame Jensen's wife. You have one job as a billionaire's wife and it's to be pretty so he doesn't cheat. Bugman, that's not useful. Bugman Hegel says, this is probably true if you married a billionaire. You know what you're signing up for and you are the implicit expectations. Let's see if the tech problems can be resolved.

[00:45:08] Bret Weinstein: This is our own little outage.

[00:45:13] Heather Heying: You know, this port or this cable or something, it hasn't worked since we've been here, honestly. Bugman Hegel says, this is probably true if you married a billionaire, you know what you're signing up for and you are aware of the implicit expectations. She did not marry a billionaire. Right. So it's ridiculous to pretend Lori is Anna Nicole Smith or Lauren Sanchez Bezos. She is allowed to age normally and look grandma-aged. She did not sign up to be a quasi prostitute and obviously transactionally understood marriage. I mean, by all means, you can advocate for the position that Jensen is then entitled to divorce her and find an upgrade for her refusal to LARP as a pre geriatric blow up doll like Lauren Sanchez Bezos. I like that line very much. But if you do, you have completely lost any ability to advocate for any traditional marriage when it comes to either public or private morality. Yes, this is one of the most spot on posts that I saw this week.

[00:46:10] Heather Heying: We have become, yeah, the pre geriatric blow up dolls that are increasingly becoming the arm candy and it's not candy that I can't imagine wanting of many of these these billionaires is becoming what we expect. And also because filters because everything is is mediated by screens now, do no does no one actually interact with real people in real life anymore without filters? Like this is I will get to a few of these screenshots like she doesn't look bad.

[00:46:44] Bret Weinstein: Yeah, I don't know that picture that's right. I don't think it's very flattering.

[00:46:49] Heather Heying: Right.

[00:46:49] Bret Weinstein: No, right. She doesn't look bad. Right. So, but look, I overwhelmingly resonate with this one. But there is one kind of pushback, which is I agree, she didn't marry a billionaire billionaire. In fact, she married a peer, right?

[00:47:05] Heather Heying: She married a peer and he he wooed her and

[00:47:09] Bret Weinstein: yeah, it's a it's a story of true love between electrical engineers. It's kind of cool. Yeah. So until it's not that much is true. But I guess the point is, I don't like the culture in which the assumption is that, oh, well, if you marry a billionaire, you know what you're signing up for. And it's like, well, OK, what you're telling us then is that and there is a degree of non shockingness to this. In fact, I don't know. I've been saying this for 30 years that monogamy was going to break down and it was going to break down into polygyny as a result.

[00:47:45] Heather Heying: We're getting there.

[00:47:46] Bret Weinstein: Yeah. OK. So but point is, I don't think it should be. Look, yeah, if the billionaire is, you know, some 50 something and he's marrying a 20 something or a 30 something.

[00:47:59] Heather Heying: But that's I mean, that's that's what Hegel is is saying here, like, because, you know, how many men aren't billionaires at 20 or 25 or 30 at the standard. No one gets married at 20 anymore. But, you know, 25, 30, 35, it's rare to be a billionaire. Right. So people marrying peers with whom they expect to have families aren't generally, you know, you can have family wealth. You can have a woman who doesn't come from family wealth marrying someone with family wealth. And and I would say that doesn't apply here. Right. But he's not talking about that.

[00:48:35] Bret Weinstein: Well, what I'm arguing is that actually not only do we need to have a culture with functional mythology that gives you some guidance on how to navigate, but we also have to have a culture in which we agree to the same rules and a culture in which the silverbacks are de facto polygynous is a culture that doesn't work for all the rest of us. So I don't think we should be so signed on to the idea that, you know, because you're a billionaire, that you have escaped constraint.

[00:49:09] Heather Heying: Well, I don't think I mean, frankly, the image that Bugman Hegel here is presenting is not an appealing one because, you know, Lauren Sanchez Bezos doesn't look good to most of us. She looks like she was a blow up doll.

[00:49:23] Bret Weinstein: Yeah.

[00:49:23] Heather Heying: Like because she she's blown herself up with fillers and everything. And it doesn't it doesn't look real. It's not human. It's sort of it's it's it's not it's not what we go on.

[00:49:33] Bret Weinstein: It's like a it's a rental because the point is it's going to age, is going to age terribly. So Bezos is sure to throw her out at some point because she temporarily did something.

[00:49:46] Heather Heying: Well, so when when we used to be professors and one of the you know, I taught animal behavior a lot, as you know, and I taught sexual selection, uh, including the various parameters in mostly non-human, but also human cultures that create the conditions for monogamy or polygamy, usually polygyny, like one man, multiple women, or, you know, one frog, multiple one male frog, multiple female frogs, depending. And, you know, almost always it was it was fun to play the game in classes that I hadn't exposed this to before and say, okay, you know, men, you know, men in the class, you know, how many of you think that polygyny sounds kind of cool? And like a bunch of men like, am I allowed to say yes? Yeah, that sounds pretty great, right? And, you know, women, how cool does that sound? Like, no one, like, no one thinks that sounds cool. And, you know, privately, most men are probably thinking like, yeah, I think I guess. Yeah, sure.

[00:50:41] Heather Heying: And then when you just do the math for people and you show them what that means, because for other reasons, sex ratios tend to even out in population. So assuming a one to one sex ratio, that is to say, unless you're a population that has just gone through war, in which you have way too few men for the number of women of reproductive age who are out there, if you embrace polygyny, what you're doing is allowing the silverbacks, the very, very few men to just run through a bunch of women, leaving a bunch of men without any who will then become enraged and angry and start behaving in ways that no one approves of. This is just the math of it.

[00:51:23] Bret Weinstein: Yes. In fact, there are ways for the resources to be distributed that it is bad, but not intolerable for women. The people it's worst for are men. And if you're low ranking,

[00:51:41] Heather Heying: all men, but the like couple on, yeah, the people it's worse for are the children.

[00:51:45] Bret Weinstein: Well, of course. And it is self destructive for this reason. But the point I want to get through is the men at the top win from the situation. All the other men breed lower down the hierarchy until you get to the men who don't breed at all. So it's a disaster for men. It is bad for women, but you can imagine if let's say we just limit the characteristics that make a guy desirable to fungible resources. You know, when a guy has many billions of dollars, a lot of women are better off sharing in that wealth than having some guy all to theirself who is, you know, struggling to get a job.

[00:52:30] Heather Heying: If, you know, as here, Bugman Hegel says, if, if you're, if what you're looking for is an understanding of human behavior and a model for your own life that is entirely transactional, yeah, in which everything that you value can be treated as a commodity, then polygyny can be okay for women because the things that aren't quantifiable, that don't work as commodities, which are relationship and love and longing and loyalty and, and history and emotion of all sorts don't work in that situation. But do you get enough stuff to have a nice house? If you're, you know, sharing a man who has a billion with nine other women, sure. Okay, good. You got enough stuff. Do a lot of people not have enough stuff? Sure. Am I minimizing their plight by suggesting that stuff isn't the end all and be all of relationship? No. In fact, I am not. Well, it's not actually fundamentally about the stuff.

[00:53:27] Bret Weinstein: It's pick your failure mode.

[00:53:28] Heather Heying: Yeah.

[00:53:28] Bret Weinstein: Right. And that's the problem is that we have the sense that we have a functional color, functional culture, because we have a legacy culture where the bridges still stay up. We have a radically dysfunctional culture that is going to collapse if we don't solve this very problem, which we can't figure out how to solve because everybody has spotted some perk that they want and they're going to accept some failure mode for it. There's nobody defend except for the religious folks. There's nobody defending a actually known to work solution to this problem. And, you know, it's as simple as that. If you want the civilization to function, you got to fix this issue. I don't think trad works. I know you don't think trad works.

[00:54:16] Heather Heying: I mean, for exact, I mean, it's there's just there's too much. There's too much. There's too much risk there. And there's too much left on the table for half the human population. There are people of both sexes, many more women than men, who will be totally satisfied in a so-called trad lifestyle. But almost everyone has actually something they want to be doing in the world that goes beyond the confines of their of their own property. And the trad life as imagined now doesn't really allow that for women. I think, you know, one of the one of the mistakes of trad as a as a model for anything is that it forgets that actually at the point that women were mostly like actually fully doing work inside their own property lines, you had men mostly doing work inside their own property lines as well. And not talking now about the 1950s and sort of, you know, Mad Men talking about an agrarian lifestyle in which, you know, the women and the men were both were integrated, doing necessary, absolutely important fundamental work of the farm, say, every single day.

[00:55:28] Heather Heying: And if either of them died, there would be trouble.

[00:55:32] Bret Weinstein: Yeah, I would argue that one of the fundamental issues with trad is that it isn't traditional masquerading as traditional.

[00:55:39] Heather Heying: It has men going out and doing some kind of bullshit office job.

[00:55:42] Bret Weinstein: I mean, it has features that are long standing. But it is not, you know, the problem is, which you really want is a system that has proven itself over a long period of time. And, you know, short of the Amish who are being de-Amished in New York, right short of the Amish,

[00:56:00] Heather Heying: is there something specific happening?

[00:56:02] Bret Weinstein: Yeah, understanding is they're being forced into vaccines. Oh, God. Right. So anyway, short of something like the Amish, where there has been a concerted effort to draw a line somewhere and not modernize beyond that point, there is no trad. So we're forced to do something that is at least novel. But, you know, the question is, what can you do when you don't have a long standing culture to simply pass on to your children that they can deploy? Right? That's where we are.

[00:56:38] Heather Heying: Okay, let's, yeah, let's see a little bit more from Twitter this week. Someone is pushing back against the like, look, she's let herself go. She's not letting herself go. This woman says she has naturally hair colored and styled to maximize the waves. She dresses appropriately showing her lovely shoulders. These men simply lacking a certain taste to which someone says someone else responds. Those who say she let herself go want her to have done plastic surgery. And that's fine, but be honest about what you demand of women. Lori is styled and works with her natural features not against them. She shines bright from the inside. You can't fake a good soul. I think there's obviously projection happening there. Who knows? Like I don't know if she has a good soul. But yes, the simultaneous demands to not play the gross promiscuous game that we were talking about last week with the Russell Brand case, but also you need to continue to look like you're in your 30s.

[00:57:38] Heather Heying: Once you're in your 60s, you can't have both of those. You can't have both of those also demanding that women look the way that you want them to look, isn't actually what women are for. Women aren't for men any more than men are for women. We are all here as humans, hopefully engaging with each other. And if we're lucky in long-term relationships in which we are each doing things for the other, but not for the entire other sex.

[00:58:06] Bret Weinstein: Right. I would say this is part of the culture where we have fetishized hot, which fades with age and don't recognize beauty, which doesn't. And the problem is, you've got a bunch of addicts. These people are addicted to hot and hot is not something they should be pursuing in the first place. Right. Hot is about men looking to reproduce without commitment. Right. Not good for civilization to give those men a pass. I think spouses have an obligation to, you know, age as gracefully as they can. Right. That's something that you, you owe your spouse, but the expectations that are being set by a, an absurdly superficial and consumption oriented culture that frankly talks as if it knows what relationships are. But, you know, frankly, you just don't have that many models.

[00:59:12] Heather Heying: That's a good segue from what you just said. The next screenshot. Bunker Dweller says, look at Jensen's wife. He looks like he's dancing with his elderly mother. She's a multi-billionaire with access to any procedures, treatments, and I didn't include the whole rest of his tweet. You can imagine what it says. Someone says in response, there should be no 65 year old woman should turn herself into a wax and botulism filled freak like Lauren Sanchez or Kimberly. How do you pronounce that? Not every day is meant to be horror ween, but this woman looks like she's 75 or 80, not 65. She let herself go and looks more like his mom than his wife. I'm baffled when I see a really fit man who obviously takes his nutrition and physical fitness seriously with a woman who seems to have given up or the inverse, a beautiful, well-kept woman with a pot-bellied hog. You obviously have very different routines. How are you a cohabitating couple? But in this instance, she could be a knockout ten.

[01:00:09] Heather Heying: He still wouldn't be able to keep from sticking his dick in other women. So this, you know, this obviously got a lot of pushback, as you can imagine, because she's not simply taking one of the positions. And, you know, my first reaction to all of this was, what the hell are any of you doing talking about her appearance at all, full stop, just be done with it? But I will say that I had seen this picture and I thought, oh, she does look old because of her posture, because she's got the old woman posture that I feel like used to be more common, that is often reflected, a reflection of some osteoporosis and frankly, maybe just a lot of screen time and of not being, of not sort of knowing how to sit and of doing physical activity. And it's true that the pictures of them from when they were younger, they look, I hate this language, but it looks matched. They look like they're appropriate for another.

[01:01:12] Heather Heying: And it looks like he's gotten high on his own increasing fame and fortune. But to match that, he is also taking care of himself. He looks like a man in his 60s who was fit and taking care of himself. And in this picture anyway, she looks like she's not. And I don't know if that's true, but I do agree with this analysis, which is I wonder how you're a different approach to your own sort of physical environment, which includes your own body.

[01:01:52] Bret Weinstein: So I'm annoyed at internet culture. Not hard to be. Really? Yeah, I am annoyed at internet culture because I feel like it is prone to this kind of very simplistic, everything is a two-sided issue. I know which side I'm on. Therefore, all of the arguments on the other side are not true. And all of the arguments on my side are true. Right. Okay. Sorry, not how logic works. So in any case, he looks good for his age in these pictures. She doesn't. But I don't know if these pictures are representative, but I will also say, you know, one of the things she looks good here. Yeah. I think she does look good there. One of the things that is true is that producing children is hard on the body. And this person has produced children with this man. And that

[01:02:58] Heather Heying: belongs to the equation. Yes. Yes. So she, this is what marriage is. There is sacrifice. There is literal sacrifice in terms of bodily health and longevity to producing children.

[01:03:12] Bret Weinstein: Yeah.

[01:03:12] Heather Heying: Okay.

[01:03:13] Bret Weinstein: One other thing I wanted to say though, is you've got a, what you're really hearing from a lot of these excuse making accounts is a sort of, you know, pseudo sophisticated. Well, we have these titans. You can imagine what they're going to get up to and more power to them effectively. Yeah. And my opinion would be what you actually have is a lot of different grotesque failure modes. Right. You have, you know, whatever it is that Elon is doing where, you know, he is, I mean, look what he's doing. If you actually think that your genes getting into the future is, is where it's at, which I don't, but if you did, yeah, he's taking a very rational approach where he has freed himself from, freed himself from the obligation of a relationship. He's effectively created a financial, he's created a surrogate where the surrogate is not just gestating a child, but is going to raise the child and the surrogates more or less know what they're signing up for.

[01:04:24] Heather Heying: I mean, it's this, it's techbro, typical reductionist, pseudoscience.

[01:04:28] Bret Weinstein: Well, you know, as, as you've pointed out in a number of places, this transhumanism stuff is a hell of a drug. And what you have is people who feel entitled to have whatever they want to reorganize the rules of how everything works so that they can just simply have it.

[01:04:49] Heather Heying: And it's like they're kindergartners, but that's not fair.

[01:04:53] Bret Weinstein: Well, it is. It's juvenile. On the other hand, the other, the problem at the interface of these two things is you do have some of these people who do appear capable in a way that matters, right? Elon is doing whatever he's doing with women and children. At the same time, he is presiding over, you know, companies catching rockets out of thin air, which changes our relationship to space. I don't know what to do with those two things, except to notice that both of them are true simultaneously.

[01:05:28] Heather Heying: Right. Both of them are true simultaneously. And maybe we should be able to recognize the remarkable, unique genius of individuals and not then imagine that the rest of their lives in their rest of their lives, they have it going on because very often they do not. Indeed, in part, because that access, that skill has given them access to things, which they have had no experience learning how to deal with.

[01:05:56] Bret Weinstein: And actually, oh, this is tough. Actually, trade-offs being what they are, you might imagine that in the masters of the extremely complicated, that there would be extreme failure modes when it comes to the complex.

[01:06:15] Heather Heying: Of course, they're looking to spreadsheet the world. They're looking for cells that have discrete entries that end up being them, and then some at the end and say, okay, now I got it. Again, it's reductionist. It's metric heavy. It's pseudoscientific. But it comes in the guise of, well, it comes in the guise of three of the four initials in STEM. Right. It's missing the science part. It's got tech. It's got engineering. It's got math. But without the science, without the actual, like, hypothetical... And there are no static rules, and there are not going to be static outcomes. Like, yes, with your rockets, maybe, but with your relationships? No. Of course, they're not gonna get it.

[01:06:56] Bret Weinstein: Okay, so then it seems to me you're watching a failure mode across civilization in which women are being reduced to hotness as a metric and men are being reduced to financial escape velocity. Yeah, right. You've got to get into the billionaire class to be enviable, and and you got to be tall. Oh, of course. So these... These are aspirational models, so people are making excuses for men and women who are extreme in one metric and predictably fail in all of the other metrics, and that's a horrifying way to create mythology.

[01:07:44] Heather Heying: Yeah, okay. Let's get... I have a few more, but I just, I definitely want to get to the end, cuz the last guy really knows what he's talking about. Colonel Kurtz, from... What's the...

[01:07:59] Bret Weinstein: Apocalypse Now.

[01:08:00] Heather Heying: No, but the original, the book. Oh, Heart of Darkness. Darkness, yeah. Does file under hard truths. Okay. Yes. "We all know some people will cheat no matter what. Maybe Jensen Huang is one of those. But don't try to tell me with a straight face the woman who has billions of dollars her disposal yet chooses to wear granny glasses, a Karen haircut, no makeup, terrible bent-over posture..." So this is one of these guys. I don't really need to read all of it. Wasson Watch Company says, "Hard to disagree. Jensen and Lori Huang have been married for 41 years. They are 63 and 65 respectively." Respectively. "If Lori looks grandmotherly, it's because she is." I'm all... I mean, I don't actually know if her kids have kids, but she obviously could be at 65. "I'm all for eating healthy, taking care of yourself, good hygiene, etc. But a 65-year-old woman is allowed to look like a 65-year-old woman. And that is no excuse for a man to cheat on her.

[01:08:54] Heather Heying: Billionaire or not, be faithful." Good. Yeah. And here I'm not showing the video, but just some quotes from this Jensen Huang interview. He says building Nvidia cost him his kids' childhood. While he was building the company, his wife Lori ran the home, and his kids grew up watching him from the crowd. "I missed all their karate tournaments," he says. "I missed a lot. You need somebody amazing like my wife. She took care of everything. I've missed most of theirs. They've been to all of mine." So I don't know when he had those revelations, but it seems like they were likely at the same moment that he was off with several other women. So just one more of these sort of grotesque, simplistic tweets, and on the response of a couple of responses to it. Bunker Dweller says, "Look at his wife. She has the post-menopause short haircut that women get that screams de-sexualization. There's no doubt in my mind that she's no longer interested in having sex with Jensen. Jensen is fit, a silver fox, and had 150 billion dollars.

[01:09:59] Heather Heying: Women came on to him daily. He's a magnet for women, older, wealthy, attractive, and powerful. At home, his wife most likely had a permanent headache." Man, this guy sounds like a winner. "Would you have the personal strength to walk the straight and narrow and resist temptation that was literally thrown your direction daily while your partner turned into your grandmother at home?" writes Bunker Dweller. Well, Meghan Murphy, who is on it, says, "This kind of commentary is essentially an argument against marriage. Why would a woman marry if this is the common mindset? Great. These men on one hand complain that women are destroying Western civilization by declining to marry and start families, then at the same time inform women that if they dare age, their husband will stop loving them and publicly humiliate them by cheating." And this guy named Bret Weinstein responds to Meghan Murphy and says, "It's really an argument for polygamy, where wealthy and powerful men hoard sexual opportunity of all kinds. It's bad for almost everyone: women, men who are not the top, children, and civilization at large."

[01:10:58] Heather Heying: And there was a lot more the internet this week, but that seems like a decent encapsulation of this particular argument, in which there were, you know, I picked three of the stupidest, shallowest takes on "Look at her. She deserves what she gets." Yeah, and a lot of somewhat more nuanced takes that are basically saying, "If that's how you feel, why do you think we want us, we should settle down and marry you?" Then what's the option? Like, are these, is the, the celebrity, the promiscuous celebrity landscape that we discussed last week, and the marriage, but no, you're gonna get thrown over at the point that you start aging naturally, like every human being does? Are those the only two options for women that are being promoted here? In which case, no wonder the people aren't falling in love, the people aren't actually creating family and engaging in romance, because where's the romance in either of those options?

[01:12:01] Bret Weinstein: No, it's, it's a flat-out disaster, and and the problem is, it's not like that thing can fail and civilization can keep going based on other stuff, right? The ability of people to reproduce themselves through a family, we don't have a replacement for that. We shouldn't be looking for... So in light of the fact that this is how at a narrow scale we reproduce ourselves, this is also how our, our civilization reproduces itself. We are watching the collapse of our civilization, and it is manifest at every scale, and it's an emergency. And what we're watching on the internet is everybody's psychology is being spilled out, and the errors in their understanding of where they are and what its implications are are all over the place.

[01:12:56] Heather Heying: Well, it's, it's static, and it's short-time horizon, and everyone is imagining that however, whatever they are right now is how they will always be and what they will always want and the only thing they will ever have. And the idea of actually having created a life together, a family together, a lifetime together, decades of memories and experiences shared together, seems to not compute. It doesn't even seem to be possible to enter it into the framework for, for some of these accounts.

[01:13:27] Bret Weinstein: So I had a back-channel communication with Meghan Murphy after that public communication, and thus the upshot of it is: people have no idea what they've given up. Right, they're addicts who are addicted to something, but they have no idea what they traded for it. And if they did, I think if they spent five minutes in their future self, either in the path that they've chosen against or the path that they're on, this would be no contest.

[01:14:00] Heather Heying: Right, but it's, I mean, it's, it's junk everything. It's, it's, it's bread and circuses. It's whatever is titillating now, whatever, whatever I want to put in my mouth or the other part of my body right now, that's what I'm gonna do. Yeah, because life is offered it, and you know, maybe there's no tomorrow,

[01:14:18] Bret Weinstein: right? And it is all very nihilistic and decidedly transhuman, which is a mistake. Transhumanism is a mistake, and the reason it's a mistake is because you've got a bunch of people who have complicated- level understandings who think that they've upgraded the complex part, and they don't know enough about it to do such a thing. So when you change something complex, you should do so with the utmost trepidation. And they don't have any trepidation. They simply see progress is inherently good. And you know what? When progress is in a highly complicated modality, like how powerful your computer is, yeah, the new model is always the best one. When you're in a complicated landscape, the chances that you want the new way of being are almost zero, right? The fact is, if you've changed something significant, you're gonna be paying the cost of everything you didn't know about what you did, inevitably. So we should be very careful about changing fundamentals, and there's nothing more fundamental than, you know, I mean, for, we're mammals. We're mammals, and the fact is, the way that we reproduce is everything, because not only are we mammals, we are the mammal with the most extreme version of our dual inheritance evolutionary mode, in which you are passed genes in one way, and then on a different channel you're passed the software that allows you to function, right? This is fundamental. You can't just upend it. And I'm struck by...

[01:15:51] Bret Weinstein: There was another story this week. I almost hate to bring it up, some stories, but it involves a scandal that is, I don't think it's a scandal for the right reason. It may in fact be a setup. Basically, it unveiled the fact that there is a... I'm losing my thread here, but there is a guy in, I think he's at Anthropic. He works at Anthropic, it's his day job, and he set up a business to, to host consensual non-consent, effectively a violation of consent, parties, that has become very, like, important in the social culture of Silicon Valley. And the reason it's a scandal this week is that a woman claims that her... The organization is called something like Red Means No.

[01:16:56] Heather Heying: So what, what's the setup? If you show up, you've consented?

[01:17:00] Bret Weinstein: Yes, unless you say red.

[01:17:01] Heather Heying: Okay, right. By showing up, you're in.

[01:17:05] Bret Weinstein: Yeah, you're agreeing to have your consent violated until you say red, which, look, not saying any laws are being violated here. I'm not saying I want people told you can't do this, but I want people to understand why they shouldn't, right? Turning present its strangers? Well, you know, it could be. It's Silicon Valley. So yeah, it's strangers and

[01:17:28] Heather Heying: strangers and strange bedfellas.

[01:17:30] Bret Weinstein: Exactly. But anyway, the point is, somehow this is playing some role in the culture of the AI companies, especially OpenAI and Anthropic.

[01:17:41] Heather Heying: What's the sex ratio at these parties?

[01:17:43] Bret Weinstein: Well, that's just... Do you want to show the screenshot that I sent you ice?

[01:17:47] Heather Heying: This is, this is...

[01:17:48] Bret Weinstein: Okay. So this is the Washington Free Bacon.

[01:17:51] Heather Heying: Did you call it bacon?

[01:17:53] Bret Weinstein: Beacon. Okay. It's past noon.

[01:17:58] Heather Heying: You want free bacon. Yeah, everything free with you. Free bacon, free.

[01:18:02] Bret Weinstein: Okay. "An AI researcher at Anthropic runs a business that hosts consensual non-consent orgies in the Bay Area. Filings reviewed by the Free Beacon apparently show those orgies have been subject to sexual assault allegations and sparked a debate in the AI industry attitudes towards women, of whom, women, some of whom report feeling pressured to attend the orgies in order to advance their careers." So anyway, and then we click through so we can read. This is the Red Means No site. I can't quite read it. Can we enlarge that? All right. Well, it...

[01:18:51] Heather Heying: Anyway,

[01:18:59] Bret Weinstein: basically suggested actually this, I can, maybe consensual non-consent thing is especially prevalent in women's fantasies, which I believe is accurate.

[01:19:13] Heather Heying: What does CNC mean?

[01:19:16] Bret Weinstein: Consensual non-consent.

[01:19:17] Heather Heying: Okay, it's not a... I have a different understand...

[01:19:21] Bret Weinstein: Yes, you have a mechanical understand...

[01:19:24] Heather Heying: Stands for it, but there's one in the garage. But anyway, okay. Yeah, it says, "CNC is a disproportionately female-preferred kink." Is it? And RMN, what's RMN? This, Red Means No. Yeah. "Exists to give women a safe space to explore..." My god, I'm sorry. "And RMN exists to give women a safe space to explore arousal that might be less welcomed in more traditional spaces." Wow, that is, I mean, that is at one level brilliant, like, using the woke language to get women who are wanting to advance their careers and not sure about this. Well, look,

[01:19:59] Bret Weinstein: I will tell you, as a non-participant in this culture but an observer of it, this is the scuttlebutt, which is that this is a tremendously common fantasy for women that they're increasingly being encouraged to explore it. Whatever it is,

[01:20:15] Heather Heying: but look at considerable risk here. What is a common fantasy for women,

[01:20:22] Bret Weinstein: having her consent violated?

[01:20:24] Heather Heying: Being, like, but at the level of, what's the, that's the Christmas song that was getting a lot of grief recently. It's called "Baby, It's Cold Outside." Yeah, right. I don't know what it's actually called. That could be understood as her having her consent violated. And, but because it's a back-and-forth and she's not really dedicated to no, and he is providing all of the ways to make it easier for her to side to stay. That, that, because we've talked about that song before. I like that song. The idea that that was the thing being canceled is insane, because as I've said before, and I've been saying since I was in my 20s or even in my late teens, sorry guys, because that was when third-wave feminism was showing up, and, but, like, to Take Back the Night walks with, like, women walking practically naked down the street. It's like, you know, don't do that. Don't do that, because in part, no doesn't always mean no, and that's part of the problem with consent culture, right?

[01:21:22] Heather Heying: So no doesn't always mean no, and "Baby, It's Cold Outside," and like, yes, that, yes, being convinced you do something that you weren't totally convinced of is different from this.

[01:21:36] Bret Weinstein: Unfortunately, I mean, you know how I feel. I think that song is wonderful, charming. There's no violation of consent there. Persuading somebody, this is perfectly consistent with a wholesome relationship that is in the process of forming. There's nothing wrong with that song. The idea... Look, I'll just lay my cards on the table. You do not want to normalize rape. You just don't. It's not yours to do. If there is some tendency to steer in the direction of taboo because it's exciting, and of course violating consent is taboo, and therefore one can play in this space, this is garbage. You don't have a right to do this to civilization. For one thing, when you play this way, you are creating the conditions that are going to cause women who did not agree to this bullshit to be raped. That's what you're doing. You're making rape sexy. Stop it. Right. Now, that does not mean that this guy who did something apparently legal...

[01:22:42] Heather Heying: The guy who created this.

[01:22:43] Bret Weinstein: Yeah, Aaron...

[01:22:45] Heather Heying: I don't... You haven't used the guy's name, but the guy who created the No Means Red Means Now, whatever it means.

[01:22:49] Bret Weinstein: No, I'm not. The problem is at the level of the culture. The problem is at the level of this being cool, and it being cool enough that it's apparently a big deal in the, you know, employee culture of two corporations on which the fate of humanity may be resting. This is absurd, right? That this is, like, an important thing, you know, having your consent violated. You know, yes, this is a very clever way of doing it. But no, it's bad, and what it speaks to is a culture in which the decent stuff, which was broken, has now been replaced by stuff that is decidedly not decent. Right. And yeah, I get it. I'm gonna be accused of being a prude for, like, the 4,000th time. But watch where your culture is going. It's getting worse by the frickin hour, right? This is not a good idea. So there's that. That's a snapshot of where the culture is. Yeah, right. But now I want to go to the flip side of this social coin. Yeah. So there's a question about what happened at Nvidia, and why Huang has been thrown out.

[01:24:04] Bret Weinstein: It has been alleged that this is effectively a coup, that there are people who want him out, and this was a good way of doing it because he made it easy for them, right? So was this woman he was sleeping with an actual spy? The evidence isn't so great, but maybe. Right. On the other hand, how secure do we actually think these companies are, given that, you know, you don't have normal rules of marriage or anything else that would allow you to even know who's sleeping with who and what's being exchanged in exchange for what, right? We don't know. So anyway, what is important is that Huang actually is not your normal Joe Blow billionaire CEO, right? I think some of these billionaire CEOs aren't really special. Yeah, right. They just ended up there because they were at the right place at the right time. Some, you know, they may have had an insight. But the point is, it could have been a lot of different people.

[01:25:06] Bret Weinstein: Who knows, maybe it's the frickin CIA deciding, "Hey, you know, we'd really like to be in control of social media, media. So maybe if we put our thumb on the

[01:25:13] Heather Heying: scales..." Doesn't look special, right?

[01:25:14] Bret Weinstein: He doesn't, yeah. So maybe the, you know, CIA decided to put the thumb on the scales so that it would be Facebook and not Myspace in order that they would control the person. Who knows? I'm not alleging it, but I'm saying there are a lot of ways this game could play out. So the problem is that Huang actually is visionary in a demonstrable way. Okay, and I want to point to two things. One is, why is Nvidia the company that has now dwarfed Apple? That turns out to be a fascinating story involving something called CUDA, which is an acronym: computer unified device architecture. Architecture. Oh, you can read my writing better than I can. That's interesting. All right, so CUDA is a 2006 initiative that apparently comes from Huang.

[01:26:12] Heather Heying: Initiative within the company.

[01:26:13] Bret Weinstein: Yeah, here's what it is, and I think for non-technical people, it won't be obvious why this is so important, but it was his argument. So that, basically, the idea is, Nvidia starts as a graphics card manufacturer. Why do you need a graphics card in your computer when your computer can calculate anything you want it to? Because the kind of calculations that your CPU does tend to be not massively parallel. So you can have a few cores working on important parts of a puzzle, and they spit out an answer, and the computer hums along and hums along. But when you throw at it something like 3D rendering of a flight simulator or a first-person shooter or whatever it is, the number of different little calculations that need to be done in parallel is huge. So graphics cards became a thing where you would offload the graphics calculations to a specific processor that had its own memory allocated, that could do huge numbers of these calculations at the same time, right?

[01:27:18] Bret Weinstein: That was everybody, and these weren't the only graphics cards manufacturers, and Nvidia was one of several. What Huang argued for was that those cards should be manufactured with this CUDA protocol, which basically loaded them with circuit, circuitry and software in order to do calculations that were not fundamentally graphical, even though there was no consumer for it. Okay, in 2006. And the point is, that was costly to Nvidia, that whole period until more or less the AI revolution.

[01:27:58] Heather Heying: They built capacity for which there was no existing market.

[01:28:01] Bret Weinstein: It's an if-you-build-it-they-will-come strategy, which is costly until it turns the tables on all of the competitors.

[01:28:07] Heather Heying: So do we, do you know, in the mythology of the company or of Huang, did he predict AI? Did he predict something? Was he, was it a Hail Mary? Like, was he feeling like the company needed something and they were gonna take a hit and hope for the best? Like, what? I don't have the many possibilities was in his head.

[01:28:28] Bret Weinstein: I don't know the answer, but I'm gonna guess. Can I'm welcome... I would welcome a correction from Huang or anyone else. I think what he realized was that it's a hundred percent inevitable that the massive amount of computing power that we are putting into graphics will be even more important in some realm I don't have to define, right? And so the point is, you look wisdom...

[01:28:55] Heather Heying: He saw the growth of the need for compute.

[01:29:00] Bret Weinstein: He knew that his company was pumping a huge amount of processing power into the world for the thing that it was necessary for now. But that processing power is processing power, and parallelism is parallelism, and at some point the next big thing is gonna need this stuff, and we will already have built the machinery to do it. We will have perfected it, yada, yada, yada. And he called it something brilliant, like a zero- billion-dollar market, right? So anyway, that's a really... Story, if it's true, and I assume it is. It looks to be true. What it shows,

[01:29:41] Heather Heying: that shows up entirely in non-engineering space. It's entirely in business space, right? That's business genius.

[01:29:48] Bret Weinstein: I think, you know, that's the other thing that gets said about him, is that actually he, he has both of these capabilities in spades, that he's very good at the business stuff, but he's also very good as an engineer, and that in part that was necessary, because a CEO who was hired for business stuff would not be able to withstand the pushback. Right, you can

[01:30:07] Heather Heying: imagine, has happened when Jobs was replaced at Apple,

[01:30:10] Bret Weinstein: right? So in this case, you know, he is able to keep the strategy going until it pays off at an unthinkable level. Yeah. And that's important. The other thing is, and the reason that there may have been a coup here, is that he is actually the guy who is fighting the restrictionists in the AI space now. The weird thing about the restrictionists in the AI space: you have a couple of weird Silicon Valley things overlapping, okay? On the one hand, you have effective altruism and rationalist culture, which is the core of doomerdom. These are the people who think the AI is going to turn on us, that it's inevitable, that we have to, you know, I mean, Yudkowsky famously said we should be ready to, you know, nuke data centers, like, literally.

[01:31:09] Heather Heying: The rationalists and... Who, what was the other?

[01:31:11] Bret Weinstein: Effective altruist. Effective altruist. Effective altruists are the people who are going to lead us straight to hell, but anyway. And both of these camps, if you don't believe me that they're actually crazy, look at their performance during COVID. It's very clear that these people, as much as they have some cool branding, are out of their minds. But okay, so on the one hand, you've got the restrictionists in Silicon Valley, like in the Bay Area. You've got the AI doomers, the, the rationalists and effective altruist folks. And you've got the corporate folks who are weirdly arguing, "Hey, government, step in and restrict us." And unclear 100% what that is. Yes, but in part it appears to be a business strategy designed to create what business people call a moat. So the idea is, if you have a...

[01:32:13] Heather Heying: So no one else comes in, no one else enters the market.

[01:32:16] Bret Weinstein: Right. Because the point is, just like with nuclear transfer cloning, when Dolly the sheep was cloned, it became obvious that actually this is not, doesn't require anything fancy. Once you know what broke through and got us to AI, that's impressive. The answer is, okay, well, what stops anybody and everybody from, you know, doing their own versions of these things?

[01:32:39] Heather Heying: Yeah. Quick, before there's dozens and dozens of us, let's get the government to restrict the creation of more,

[01:32:44] Bret Weinstein: right? Which folks like Alexandros Marinos compellingly argue that this is exactly the inverse of what we should do, because it creates a single point of control.

[01:32:56] Heather Heying: So anyway, also, presumably that would end up making illegal the creation of your own personal AI. In, you know...

[01:33:05] Bret Weinstein: Oh, right. Oh, yeah, right. Totally. So, so the moat, so

[01:33:08] Heather Heying: it's a move towards centralization, which, you know, if COVID taught us nothing, it should be that that is not what we need,

[01:33:14] Bret Weinstein: right? The, so the flaw in the particular market can be cured if they can convince government to do this thing, which is aided by the rationalist effective altruist folks who are shouting doom at the same time that they're involved in consensual non-consent, which they love. So anyway, it's... Some, some of them do. All, but not all. Yeah, well, I don't know, but it is a big deal over there. But whatever. So Huang was the standout who was in opposition to

[01:33:53] Heather Heying: the standard among... What's the population

[01:33:55] Bret Weinstein: among the... Corporate titans.

[01:33:59] Heather Heying: Silicon Valley corporate tight...

[01:34:00] Bret Weinstein: AI titans. AI specifically, right. So this was the guy who fought export restrictions on chips capable of doing fancy AI stuff,

[01:34:11] Heather Heying: which, of course, has been suggested that's related to his relationship with the, right, the maybe spy.

[01:34:17] Bret Weinstein: But so the question then is, let's say you take the human story of the Huangs, their marriage, extramarital affairs, the danger that Huang was compromised and that this was putting, you know, that Nvidia was putting the, you know, the West at risk by conveying secrets to the Chinese through this spy, also named Huang, interestingly. Inconveniently. That should be a taboo. But anyway,

[01:34:58] Heather Heying: well, and separately, incidentally, apparently her husband introduced them.

[01:35:02] Bret Weinstein: Excuse me, what now?

[01:35:05] Heather Heying: Here's the Wall Street Journal: "A mystery businessman introduced Jensen Huang to his paramour. It was her husband." And "for two years, Kang appeared to accept his wife's romantic relationship with the Nvidia CEO and spoke openly of their closeness." All right, the whole thing just... But yeah.

[01:35:24] Bret Weinstein: All right. Anyway, but imagine that you've got, and it, you know, so like the Russell Brand thing, where it's like, okay, that's gross, and I don't want to have to think about these people's broken dynamics. On the other hand, there's something really important resting on it. You know, in Russell Brand's case, they are normalizing the ability to railroad you in court and lock you up in prison if your opinions become inconvenient, by using,

[01:35:54] Heather Heying: decades later, on the scantiest of evidence, if you can even call it that,

[01:35:58] Bret Weinstein: right? And on the basis of some kind of weird conflation of, you know, if, if the event described happened, then consent may have been violated. But was the gap between what had been consented to and what happened the gap between rape and not rape? No. So it's like a bait and switch with respect to what the crime is, if there was a crime at all. But anyway, the point is, that thing results in an important voice being taken off the stage and literally locked up. And I don't know if you caught that his wife brought a message from Russell and presented it.

[01:36:45] Heather Heying: Yes, apparently the UK courts think that this was an illegitimate move and are going after her for it,

[01:36:51] Bret Weinstein: right? So if you, if you watch last week's show and you weren't sure what to think about our understanding of the case, this is a flashing red light that we were correct, right? There is no way that anywhere in the West his wife's right to say whatever she thinks or whatever message she wants to convey should be a matter of, you know, governmental interest. Fuck that. No, this is the West. Let's suppose that he was locked up legitimately. Let's suppose that he committed exactly the crime he's accused of. This is still his wife's right to say what she thinks. So anyway, yes, this is an emergency in the Russell Brand case because something very important rests on it. In the Huang case, something very important rests on this too, because what it is is a class of people, billionaires. All of them are behaving badly, or almost all of them are behaving badly, which means you can go after the ones who stand in the way of the policy that you want. You can get them thrown out of their companies, and that is being hidden by this, you know, human story that you can't look away from.

[01:38:03] Heather Heying: Yeah. No, I do. It feels to me these two stories, both of which got me, couldn't look away from them, right? And I, it was easier actually to take, for me to take on the Russell Brand story, because it, it felt more obvious, and I didn't feel personally involved, because that was a culture in which everyone was playing these games that I have always found insidious and grotesque. And this one felt like it, you know, it got to my amygdala, like, very... How disgusting. Like, I really had much more of a response of, like, what a degenerate, with regard to Jensen Huang than we're going to Russell Brand, because of the promise and the oath and the expectation of loyalty, long commitment and such. And none of that actually matters, except that I would ask our viewers, our listeners, to think about when they are, when they are caught by a story like, "Oh, I don't usually, I'm not usually gonna spend time on social media, but that, who, what, what, what now? What's going on?" Why that story? Like, why that story? In both of these cases, in the case of both of these men, both of whom behave badly, right? In the case of both of these men, why them and not others?

[01:39:25] Heather Heying: And, and, and as much as you used to make fun of this question, we would shout, like, why now? Like, really, why now? Why, why at this moment for both of them?

[01:39:35] Bret Weinstein: Let me just say, reason I used to make fun of that is because it was a go-to argument for people who didn't have a different one. Yeah, and the point is, well, it's gonna be some time. But in the case when there is actually a reason, like Huang is standing in the way of a policy that is desired by his peers, why now is a very good question. Likewise with Russell Brand, and, you know, especially in Russell Brand's case, the delay between the alleged crime and the prosecution and everything that's gone on between it raises that why now question in a very profound way. Yeah. More? No, I think that about does it for my side.

[01:40:26] Heather Heying: Yeah, me too. I think maybe next week we won't talk about the degeneracy of famous men.

[01:40:33] Bret Weinstein: Well, we'll see how they behave over the course of the next week, all of them. That's a good point. I don't know. We'll see if anything forces us to discuss it.

[01:40:43] Heather Heying: Yeah.

[01:40:44] Bret Weinstein: Yeah, and we will address the question of why now in whatever case it is that we will be talking about then.

[01:40:50] Heather Heying: We'll discuss why now then.

[01:40:51] Bret Weinstein: Yes. Yeah, right.

[01:40:53] Heather Heying: All right. All right. Thank you. Thank you for joining us again, as always. Yes. We will be back on, actually, next Wednesday, the day before American Thanksgiving, by which time all of you good, patriotic Americans should have bought your turkey and perhaps start brining it, or whatever it is that you do. That's, that's what we do with ours. And we'll see you for a conversation about we know not what. And until then, remember to be good to the ones you love, eat real food, and get outside.

[01:41:32] Bret Weinstein: Be well, everybody.

Next
Next

Israel, Gaza, and the Logic of Genocide: Dr. Jonathan Hudson on DarkHorse