Israel, Gaza, and the Logic of Genocide: Dr. Jonathan Hudson on DarkHorse

Episode: The Inside Rail
Published: November 16th, 2026
Host: Dr. Bret Weinstein
Guest: Dr. Jonathan Hudson
Podcast: DarkHorse Podcast / Inside Rail
Runtime: 2:27:13
Transcript source: SRTX transcript file

Video: Watch on YouTube
Rumble: Watch on Rumble
Audio: Listen on Spotify · Apple Podcasts

Summary

Bret Weinstein speaks with his former PhD student Dr. Jonathan Hudson, a Holocaust and genocide scholar, about Israel, Gaza and October 7. Both start from a shared premise: that genocide is an evolutionary pattern, and that refusing to analyze it that way removes the best tool for recognizing and preventing it. Bret notes at the outset that their positions are roughly the reverse of what listeners might expect. Hudson, who has no personal connection to Israel, is more sympathetic to the Israeli position. Bret, who grew up in a secular Jewish home, is increasingly troubled by Israel's conduct and by what it means for Jews in the diaspora.

The conversation opens with why Hudson recently left Britain for Vietnam, including the grooming gang scandal and what both describe as a facilitated invasion of the West. It then turns to October 7. Hudson lays out what he has found about the attack: the factions involved, the warnings Israeli intelligence received beforehand, including the Jericho Wall plan and the analyst known as “V,” and the unarmed surveillance soldiers who reported unusual activity. Bret argues that the scale of the security failure, Benjamin Netanyahu's facilitation of money to Hamas, and false atrocity claims such as the “40 beheaded babies” story together suggest something other than ordinary incompetence. Hudson agrees Netanyahu should have resigned but does not see him as the villain Bret does. The two also disagree over the evidence on sexual violence on October 7, and on allegations against the IDF.

In the final hour Bret sets out his model of civilizations built on kinship versus reciprocity, and argues that “the two teams are not the Israelis and the Muslims” but those who oppose genocide and those who think it is the only way. Hudson responds that genocide never has a genuinely defensive element, and that he has never seen a territory as genocidal as Gaza. They discuss the Trump administration's renderings of a rebuilt Gaza, Babi Yar, whether Israel is an apartheid state, and the concentration camp comparison, which Bret withdraws at the end after Hudson's rebuttal.

About the Guest

Dr. Jonathan (Jonny) Hudson holds a PhD in Holocaust and Genocide Studies. Bret Weinstein served as his major advisor; his doctoral project centered on Nazi atrocities, especially the killing center Treblinka, and on the evolutionary dimension of the Holocaust. A British citizen, Hudson says he has studied the Holocaust for around 20 years and worked in Holocaust education. He taught in Grimsby and Bradford, has lived and worked in five countries including China, and recently moved to Vietnam. This is his third appearance on DarkHorse.

About the Host

Bret Weinstein is an evolutionary biologist and host of the DarkHorse Podcast, which examines science, institutions, politics, culture, and the challenges facing Western civilization. The Inside Rail is his long-form interview series.

Sponsors

  • BAERSkin Tactical: Text DARKHORSE to 36912 for $20 off the BAERSkin Hoodie 5.0.

  • Branch Basics: Use code DARKHORSE for 15% off sitewide at branchbasics.com.

  • Mars Men: Get 50% off for life, free shipping and three free gifts at mengotomars.com/darkhorse.

Mentioned in This Episode

Join Us

Join DarkHorse on Locals! Get access to our Discord server, exclusive live streams, live chats for all streams, and early access to many podcasts: darkhorse.locals.com

Check out the DHP store! Epic tabby, digital book burning, saddle up the dire wolves, and more: darkhorsestore.org

Key Questions Answered in This Episode

Why do Bret Weinstein and Jonathan Hudson study genocide as an evolutionary phenomenon?

Because they argue that treating genocide as madness hides how it works. At 00:33:52 Bret Weinstein says: “You and I are committed to the idea that by ignoring the evolutionary component of genocide, the evolutionary analysis of that historical process, we have eliminated the tool that is most likely to be able to banish that pattern forever. In other words, we've blinded ourselves to what genocide is. We tell ourselves certain comforting stories about how that process unfolds. It's the result of monsters who lose their minds.” Hudson agrees; the two have worked together on the subject for over six years.

What does Jonathan Hudson think Hamas wanted from the October 7 attack?

Footage of Palestinian civilians being killed, to turn Western opinion against Israel. At 00:38:06 Hudson says: “They were trying to get footage of their own people being killed by the Israelis.” He continues that Hamas “did the most disgraceful and demonic acts imaginable because they knew that Israel would have to respond in a way. And then they went and scuttled into their tunnels and put their women and children above them.” Earlier, at 00:37:33, he says Hamas also aimed to disrupt Israel's normalization process with Saudi Arabia.

What warnings did Israel receive before October 7?

Hudson lists several, beginning at 00:58:25. At 00:58:56 he describes “the Jericho Wall plan which is about 40 page document that Israeli military intelligence were able to acquire. And it essentially spells out October the seventh.” He also cites warnings Shin Bet director Ronen Bar says he gave Netanyahu, an analyst in Unit 8200 known as “V” whose messages were published by the New York Times, and the young female surveillance soldiers at Nahal Oz who reported unusual activity in the days before the attack.

How much money reached Hamas with Benjamin Netanyahu's approval?

Bret Weinstein, at 00:41:28: “We learn that Benjamin Netanyahu has been financially supporting Hamas. I looked up the numbers. And I they're so remarkable I can't even believe they could be correct I question them because they're almost unfathomable. One to 2 billion dollars has gone to Hamas. At various points it's been 35 million dollars a month.” Hudson adds at 02:04:03 that “it's thought that four million a month was going to the al-Qassam Brigades during 2019 to 2021.” Bret argues this makes Netanyahu responsible for October 7 “at many different levels”; Hudson agrees he should have resigned.

Were the reports of beheaded babies on October 7 true?

Bret Weinstein and Jonathan Hudson disagree. At 01:21:28 Bret says: “I think we down now do know that babies were not beheaded that that was a false story.” Hudson replies at 01:21:41 that Dr. Chen Kugel, director of Israel's National Center of Forensic Medicine, “said that to The Media Line, bodies including babies were without heads,” while agreeing that “the 40 babies thing” was false. Bret calls lying about atrocities “a bright red line” (01:24:10); Hudson argues for some grace toward officials in the days after the attack.

What does Bret Weinstein think the Trump administration's renderings of a rebuilt Gaza reveal?

He suspects they may be a tacit admission of ethnic cleansing. At 01:44:51: “You telling me that you want to the middle of a conflict you're telling me that you want to rebuild this place with these gleaming skyscraper towers on the beach. Are you doing that for the Palestinians. Or are you admitting. That actually the Palestinians. Have lost this territory as a result of this conflict.” Hudson responds at 01:46:05 that Trump may be “trying to move the Overton window a bit because what's happened over the last 70 years is just isn't working.”

Who are the “two teams” in Bret Weinstein's view of the Middle East?

Not Israelis and Muslims, but those for and against genocide. At 01:54:29: “Children who are born in Gaza are innocent by definition because I have a western mindset. They are not future terrorists. They are undefined. They are innocent. But the point is look the two teams are not the Israelis and the Muslims. The two teams are those of us who are against genocide and those of us who think it's the only way.” The argument rests on his model of societies built on kinship versus reciprocity, laid out from 01:48:39.

Does Jonathan Hudson consider Israel's response to October 7 genocidal?

No. At 01:56:01 he tells Bret: “I think the big difference is that you can see genocidal behavior in Israel's reaction to October the 7th and I just can't see.” He argues there is “never ever a defensive element” to genocide, and at 01:56:46: “I've never seen a territory as genocidal as Gaza and I'm not condemning you know the innocents to you know the war that their leaders have dragged them into.” Later, after Hudson's rebuttal of the concentration camp comparison, Bret says at 02:25:00: “I'm persuaded that's not a good comparison. I take it back.”

Episode Chapters

00:00:00 The Holocaust Scholar Returns
00:01:35 Sponsor: BAERSkin Tactical
00:02:49 Sponsor: Branch Basics
00:04:31 Why Jonny Left Britain for Vietnam
00:10:23 The Grooming Gang Scandal
00:14:02 Is the West Being Invaded?
00:21:51 Sponsor: Mars Men
00:23:15 The Holocaust Scholar Called a Nazi
00:31:38 Where Bret and Jonny Disagree
00:36:22 What Did Hamas Want From October 7?
00:44:40 What Actually Happened on October 7
00:56:09 Incompetence or Something Else?
01:09:25 Netanyahu: Villain of October 7?
01:20:35 Exaggerations, Mistakes, or Lies?
01:43:10 Why Genocide Targets Children
01:48:30 Kinship vs. Reciprocity
01:56:07 Is Gaza Uniquely Genocidal?
01:59:47 Who Dragged Gaza Into This War?
02:08:24 Is Genocide Ever Defensive?
02:14:41 Netanyahu Doesn't Speak for Me
02:19:14 Apartheid and Concentration Camps

Search Keywords

Bret Weinstein, Jonathan Hudson, Jonny Hudson, DarkHorse Podcast, Inside Rail, Israel, Gaza, October 7, Hamas, Benjamin Netanyahu, genocide, evolutionary analysis of genocide, Holocaust, perpetrator studies, Treblinka, Jericho Wall, Unit 8200, Shin Bet, Ronen Bar, Nahal Oz, surveillance soldiers, security failure, stand-down order, Charlie Kirk, Qatari money to Hamas, al-Qassam Brigades, beheaded babies, atrocity propaganda, Chen Kugel, sexual violence October 7, UN report, Trump Gaza plan, ethnic cleansing, kinship and reciprocity, lineage against lineage violence, Babi Yar, apartheid, concentration camp comparison, Warsaw Ghetto, UNRWA, Abraham Accords, NDAA 2012, grooming gangs, Grimsby, mass migration, Britain, Vietnam, Jews in the diaspora

Related DarkHorse Episodes

Transcript

This transcript was prepared from the episode's speaker-labeled SRTX caption file and lightly consolidated into readable paragraphs. The source file begins at the episode's true 00:00:00 timecode, so no timestamp offset has been applied.

[00:00:00] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Hey folks, welcome to the DarkHorse podcast Inside Rail. I have sitting with me today, repeat guest, Jonathan Hudson. Jonathan Hudson is a PhD in perpetrator studies. In fact, he was my graduate student. I was his major advisor on his PhD project. His PhD project centered on Nazi atrocities, especially with respect to the killing center Treblinka. So he has now completed his degree. We are working on other things still surrounding the questions of genocide. Jonny, maybe before I say more about that, let me just welcome you back to DarkHorse.

[00:00:45] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Thank you very much, mate. It's first and foremost, it's just always great to chat. So, and to see you again, so, and to be on your platform. Thank you very much.

[00:00:56] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well, I'm glad to have you back. Uh, I have a certain amount of trepidation about today's topic. We are going to be talking today about Israel and Gaza. This is a discussion you and I have wanted to have for some time. It's been on the books for weeks, but in any case, the topic is so fraught that I feel a hundred percent confident that it will be widely and bring lots of undeserved bile back at at least me and maybe you. Um, but so be it. We have to, we have to confront that. Our first sponsor this week is new to DarkHorse and they're awesome. It's BAERSkin. At this time of year, almost no matter where you live, the weather can be surprising. One minute it's balmy and quiet. The next fierce wind has come out of the Arctic. Maybe you're contending with sideways rain or just really low weather. That's so gray. You've forgotten that color exists.

[00:01:54] Dr. Bret Weinstein: BAERSkin hoodie and rain jacket combo helps you stay warm and dry and keeps you outside even when the weather turns ugly. I recently got my first BAERSkin micro fleece and I loved it immediately. It's warmer than most hoodies lighter than it looks like it could be, blocks wind, looks great with 12 pockets, including an inner pocket that keeps cards and cash safe, everything is easily findable and secure. We're facing some crazy storms in the Pacific Northwest right now. And my BAERSkin hoodie is helping me keep warm and dry. Right now you can get $20 off the BAERSkin Hoodie 5.0. Just text DARKHORSE to three six nine one two, and they'll send a link straight to your phone. That's text DARKHORSE to three six nine one two for $20 off. And if you're on the move, they'll hold the deal. So it's there when you're ready. So just text DARKHORSE to three six nine one two to get 20 US dollars off your BAERSkin hoodie.

[00:02:49] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Our second sponsor this week is Branch Basics, which makes effective all natural, non-toxic cleaning products. We've been using their products for well over a year now, counters and floors in the laundry kitchen and bath. And they're great. Most cleaning products contain synthetic fragrance compounds, phthalates and harsh surfactants, all of which contribute to hormone disruption, which in turn can cause fertility issues, mood changes and thyroid dysfunction. And in the US, products don't have to disclose everything on their labels. So you don't really know what's in there. Branch Basics changes this with full transparency about their entirely non-toxic plant and mineral based ingredients. Their premium starter kit comes with one powerful concentrate that makes everything laundry detergent, bathroom cleaner, glass cleaner, even pet wash and vegetable rinse.

[00:03:35] Dr. Bret Weinstein: It's safe for babies, pets and anyone wanting to reduce their daily exposure to harmful chemicals in the new year and covers all your everyday surface cleaning needs. Branch Basics is human safe and fragrance free. And here's the good news. Branch Basics is now available everywhere you shop at Target, target.com, Amazon, and of course branchbasics.com. Tossing the toxins has never been more convenient and you can get 15% off site wide using the code DARKHORSE at branchbasics.com. The Home Essentials kit comes with the concentrate and refillable bottles for your surface cleaners, including all purpose bathroom, streak free dishwasher, tablets and laundry detergent. This kit is a great way to kickstart your human safe cleaning routine. Just use code DARKHORSE for 15% off site wide at branchbasics.com. After you purchase, when they ask where you heard about them, please make sure to mention DarkHorse.

[00:04:31] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Now, before we get to questions of Israel and Gaza, I do want to point out the last time that you were on the channel, you were living in the UK. You're a British citizen. Yeah. You have now moved to Vietnam and I think it's worthwhile for you to say a little bit about why you did that.

[00:04:51] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah. So, you know, there's, there's many, many different reasons. Um, and, uh, you know, I, it would take a whole podcast for me to go into all of them and should probably mention first that there was a, there was a lot of pull factors and my wife's Vietnamese. I love Vietnam and we've got obviously Vietnamese family and I just love the chaos and the beauty of Vietnam. Um, but that's always been there, but I hadn't made the decision until recently to move here and you know, I, I don't think that I'm quite in the position to speak as freely as I perhaps would, would like to, or I could on, on this topic. But you know, I've spoken to you before and I was just a little bit, well, not a little bit, a lot fed up of, of being in England, the current situation. And you know, I lit, I was working in Holocaust education, so I was deeply involved in the worst thing that's ever happened in human history.

[00:06:06] Dr. Jonny Hudson: So that was the information that I was processing in order for me to do my job properly, and then I was able to deal with that. I've been studying the Holocaust and I've specialized in it and I've been in that field for around 20 years. And I always thought that, you know, I would be able just to be able to just keep on going, dealing with that information. And I was surprised that it never really affected me in the way that people says it, says it might. And then I did so that was the current situation in Israel and then the current situation in the UK, where you can easily just get called racist and far right for being concerned about things that are happening quite clearly in front of your eyes. And it just got to a point where I was thinking, you know, when is enough going to be enough? You know, to be honest and more honest than I was planning on being.

[00:07:23] Dr. Jonny Hudson: When you see thousands and thousands of military aged men arriving on your shore in boats that are, in many cases, hostile to the country, and then. They are put up in in hotels for free. That I found that particularly unbearable. And I know how this sounds because I have always been from the left. I spent my entire life being a lefty, maybe like a very far lefty at some points. And when I was a teacher, if they gave me, you know, 10 years ago, I can remember being a teacher during the Syrian refugee crisis and I would do my assemblies on why aren't we letting more Syrian refugees in? So I understand what it sounds like for me to say this. But to be there's to be called like a Nazi and a racist for being a little bit concerned about like these objective facts that we can see happening in front of us. It it really does kind of wear on you.

[00:08:48] Dr. Jonny Hudson: And, you know, that's just that's only just part of the reason, but that it was a big reason to see like the disintegration of. Of the of the country like the West was, I've said to you before, the West was was making me was making me ill. And I was I was stressed in a way that I've never felt before and maybe had to do with my you know, my day job wasn't dealing with all this dreadful information. But that for many years I was able to cope with that. It was when the other stuff was piled on top of it. And, you know, I I I worked quite often in Westminster. So I would, you know, once a week, typically I'd go down there and I would see the you know, the demonstrations, the so-called pro Palestinian demonstrations that were going on and this and the rising anti-Semitism in my country. It's it was just so frustrating that I was just thinking.

[00:09:59] Dr. Jonny Hudson: You know, all of this added up by when is enough going to be enough?

[00:10:05] Dr. Bret Weinstein: And so you I will also just say you have young children. And so watching not only boatloads full of military age men being brought on shore, transported to fancy hotels, given stipends and all of that. In addition to that, you've got the grooming gang scandal, which for anybody who has any ambiguity about what's going on, there is a radical double standard being applied in Britain where to put it bluntly, you have Muslim men organizing themselves to rape British girls to and being given a pass. In fact, having their crimes covered up by British officials.

[00:11:01] Dr. Jonny Hudson: That for decades, for decades. Yeah. And that hit me particularly hard because my first teaching job in England was in a place called Grimsby. And if there's any of your audience from England, they will they will know that place. One of the most socioeconomically deprived areas of the entire country. And I'm really proud of the work that I did there. It was tough, like very tough. I'm glad that I did it, obviously, because I was able to help some of the most the people that need it the most as a teacher. But I worked with those white working class, the same kind of white working class girls that were exploited, abused and raped on an industrial scale. So, you know, I, you know, perhaps for other people, they it was more more distant because, you know, they've never had that experience of daily interactions with the kind of with the victim group.

[00:12:07] Dr. Jonny Hudson: But I did. And then, you know, the insanity of the authorities not taking it seriously because they were getting they were afraid of being accused of racism. And this is this is rape on. We've mentioned the word industrial. I think I have. I don't know if you use that word scale. It's it's truly horrifying when you read into it and you when you read into the victim statements, the fact that this was allowed to happen.

[00:12:38] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I mean, it's not even allowed to happen. I hate to cut you off, but there's something about this. There is no need for nuance. A society that watches its girls raped by foreigners. And allows it to happen is a sick society. Right. If this happened occasionally, it would be worthy of notice. But talking about this happening in a systematic way, I don't care who you are. I don't care what side of the political spectrum you're on. This is a some hostile force has lobotomized the British government at best so that it cannot see an atrocity in front of its eyes against its most vulnerable citizens.

[00:13:40] Dr. Jonny Hudson: So yeah, a mass atrocity. And now I think it's kind of slipped away again now. So I don't think anybody is really thinking about it anymore. But, you know, but, you know, we decent people are. We haven't forgotten. And, you know, has justice been delivered? Absolutely not.

[00:14:02] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well, not only that, but the facilitated invasion across the West is continuing apace. So again, it's hard to figure out how to describe this to people who aren't aware. But the international community has actually decided to do this, not just to Britain, not just to the US, to all of Europe. It has a paper thin excuse for why it wants this done. But I think to anybody with half a brain, it's obviously an attack on Western values by something that is hostile to those values. And not to put too fine a point on it, but you and I, when we get into the heart of this discussion, we'll be discussing the evolutionary interpretation of genocide. You and I have come together because you heard me describe on a podcast that genocide is clearly an evolutionary phenomenon that resonated with you. You thought, yes, of course, it has to be and decided to pursue it.

[00:15:19] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Even though in both evolutionary science and perpetrator studies, this is frowned upon, this is portrayed as irrational. So you and I are both well versed in the idea that populations. Getting rid of each other and taking over their land is an unfortunate evolutionary pattern. You're watching it happen in your home country. I'm watching it happen in my home country. And you and I both know that it's happening across the countries that we would typically refer to as Western and that that appears to be, frankly, an ancient evolutionary pattern dressed up in modern language and sensibilities in order for the people who are being displaced to be induced into ignoring it, which they are in large measure. Is that fair?

[00:16:14] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Absolutely. Yeah. And I'm going to again be more honest than I was planning on being at this stage of the podcast, but you use the word invasion. And, you know, I'm a historian, not just of, you know, modern European history of also the Middle Ages and even going further back. And is this the first time in human history where like repeated boatloads of men like turn up to break into a country and where not allowed to call it an invasion? I think it I think I think it is. And I know I could get I know what this sounds like. I could I used to I feel like I still am that guy, but I used to be that guy that would just be, you know, what I've just said, which is like trigger hysteria in me. Just like, how dare you call it? But is there a different point in human history where this this wouldn't have been called an invasion?

[00:17:25] Dr. Bret Weinstein: No, any point in which people had an irrationality, they would call it an invasion. You can look at the fact that the communities to which these groomers belong have not advocated for throwing the baddies out. Am I right about that?

[00:17:46] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I would expect I don't think there was any internal like even after the after the fact of perpetrators being caught. No one's known from within the community, to my knowledge, has gone along and supported the prosecutions. But there was no whistleblowers from within the community either, to my knowledge.

[00:18:12] Dr. Bret Weinstein: So that tells you right there that your eyes are not fooling you. Great Britain is under attack. It is under attack by military age males who do not aspire to be British, who do not their host country and are willing to participate in utterly notorious crimes against the most innocent members of society.

[00:18:39] Dr. Jonny Hudson: So also, yeah, so I've lived in five different countries now, lived and worked. I've been, you know, had like the honor of being accepted into all of these different countries. The last thing I'm looking for in Vietnam now is like is there like an enclave of British people somewhere? Is there a Church of England somewhere? I know there's some British pubs somewhere. That is absolutely the opposite of what I want. I want to be in Vietnam. I'm like I'm a guest and I love this country for accepting me in. I want to learn the language. I want to learn the cut. I read about the Vietnamese history and, you know, I often like I say to you, if I can, I run up to like Ba Dinh Square and I just I just enjoy the majesty of this incredible country. I am the last thing I want is an enclave of people like me that have just taken over an area and made it like England.

[00:19:49] Dr. Jonny Hudson: It's like the least appealing thing I can possibly think about. And it's the same when I was in. I love China. I lived in China for three years and, you know, not everybody will say that because China gets a bad rap. But I absolutely love China. It hosted me for three years and I will always love China for that. I did not want to find other people like me that had taken over like a certain area. And again, I know what this sounds like, but it's just the truth. We and I think that's the opposite to racism. I want I want the world to have its own character, like every country to have its own identity and character. And, you know, when you go and you're like I have been, you know, Japan, Poland, China, Vietnam have all welcomed me in and been amazing to me. And what I will take away from those countries is the fact that, you know, it was so and what excited me about living there, why I appreciate it so much.

[00:21:01] Dr. Jonny Hudson: And the facets that is added to my character is because it was nothing like where I was from. And I just don't I just don't get why you would go to another country and then try and make it like your own. Yeah. So you are. And like I get my you know, my far right and my race is to thinking that apparently so to some people.

[00:21:27] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Yeah, no, you're you're honoring these countries for what they are in a way that those invading the West are not. And that every immigrant is an invader. But those who are invading the West and that is clearly what's happening are dishonoring the West and being facilitated by the international community in in so doing. Here's something you should know. Great women like masculine men. What makes men masculine? Well, that's a complicated story, but the foundation of it is testosterone. Problem is the testosterone level start dropping around the age of 30. Some people supplement testosterone. But the problem is if you do that, you send the body the message that it's got plenty and it stops making whatever testosterone it was making before. Also, there are other health consequences to taking testosterone. A better approach is to adjust your set point by taking Mars Men.

[00:22:31] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Mars Men is a supplement. It's all natural and it's third party tested. What it does is it triggers your body to produce more endogenous testosterone. I've been taking Mars Men for a number of months now and I've definitely seen results, including I've watched my testosterone numbers go up in blood tests. So if you're ready to try it for a limited time, our listeners get 50 percent off for life plus free shipping and three free gifts at mengotomars.com/darkhorse. That's mengotomars.com/darkhorse for 50 percent off and three free gifts. When you check out after your purchase, they will ask you where you heard about them. Please support our show and tell them DarkHorse sent you. One last thing before we move on to the substance of our discussion. I think many, many will have missed the irony in what you said early on. You are a scholar of the Holocaust and you are concerned that in your home country that you will be accused of being a Nazi for noticing what is taking place in front of your own eyes.

[00:23:48] Dr. Bret Weinstein: That is an amazing fact that somebody who has dedicated their adult life to understanding Nazi is afraid of that accusation being leveled against them for simply identifying and discussing obvious facts.

[00:24:09] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah, well, when you get called a Nazi, you do kind of you think like I don't know if I could have lived my life to be less of a Nazi. I have no personal connection to the Holocaust or Israel, which will be relevant to our later discussion. I have a mixed race family myself. I've lived, like I've said, in five different countries. I worked for three years in a city, Bradford, a school that was 90, 95 percent Muslim. And I did my best for those kids there and I have some amazing memories and some connections that will always be with me from the working there. So you just you think about yourself sometimes when you get called a Nazi, you're like, what could I have done? Like what what like literally could I have done apart from like being worried about, you know, the current situation? You know, what more could I have done to not be called a Nazi?

[00:25:22] Dr. Bret Weinstein: No, there's there's nothing you can do. It's not possible because when people accuse you of being a Nazi, they are not actually making a an argument. What they are doing is punishing you for observing something that they want to hide. So the idea is this is this is the most potent punishment that you can deliver a civilized person is to level that accusation. And they are, you know, completely uninterested in the irony. You know, I've also been accused of being a Nazi and I'm Jewish. So, you know, they don't care that this doesn't make sense. The point is it's supposed to sting.

[00:26:08] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah, it's obviously completely absurd. And, you know, you just after a while, like, no, you come to Vietnam like and you like nobody's nobody's calling me a Nazi here. I know I'm not, you know, obviously they don't really they know who the Nazis were and stuff like that. But in terms of like the logic, if you said to Vietnam, right, so there's a thousand people that are breaking into Vietnam right now. But against the rules and regulations of Vietnam, they are literally breaking into your country right now. And then they want to be put up in a hotel like just they just having none of they're just not having this shit here. And it's just it's refreshing. It just feels like a weight has been lifted. Obviously, it's just the trans insanity would never catch on in Vietnam. Like they just they're just they're just not having that is not having it.

[00:27:21] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Like you if you want to. If you if you want to come here and work and contribute to the country and love the country, the doors open. And if I if I've got some wild ideas about like who I am. They'll be like, OK, like you might you're you're out to do. Don't fucking try and make me think that, too. So you like they're just not up for this bullshit. And it's so refreshing just to be around people that are just like pure and honest and family orientated. And, you know, we'd call them in the West. We'd probably call them socially conservative. But it's not that it's just like grounded in reality and like the pure, simple, you know, facts that we all know.

[00:28:15] Dr. Bret Weinstein: We have a word for it in the US, I assume. It's a it's used in Britain, too. But the word is sane. Do you have that word?

[00:28:26] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I do now. Yeah. So, yeah, it's just I just honestly it's just nice to get around like some sanity. And and then, you know, the news is not you know, I can. If I don't want to, I don't need to view the news so I can. And it's my choice now if I want to like step into, you know, the overbearing weight of the global situation now. And, you know, one last thing, because, you know, we have to talk about Israel. It did feel towards the end almost like an escape. Because of the domestic situation that I've spoken about already. But when you have studied war for 20 years, you realize that everything's OK until it's not. And I'm watching our involvement in the Middle East and with Russia. And I'm just thinking back to people in, you know, yeah, my people, British people in the 1930s. I'm wondering if they, you know, it was just kind of bubbling away like it is, like it was for me when I was in the UK and I just bubbling, bubbling away like, oh, this this might get bad, this might get bad.

[00:29:59] Dr. Jonny Hudson: And then you just wake up one morning and things have spilled over. And that I don't know, maybe maybe that sounds a bit extreme. But that that is the way as somebody that studied war for 20. And that is the way that I felt, you know, all the other reasons. But I was like, this this this might get really hairy. We're not we're not that far away from Russia. Well, we're actually, you know, Iran could feasibly hit us. And, you know, we've seen recently that, you know, they had they are lodged into our society as well. With their agents, they did that attack on the US US base recently. Like things could spill over into something really disastrous. And if I'm honest, I know as I'm saying this, I'm thinking that this sounds a little bit crazy. But I'm thinking, you know, something something big might happen. And I do know people in the military.

[00:31:00] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I worked with them in my last job. And I did say to them, like, am I just is this is something could something big happen? And like this guy was saying, actually, I think the same.

[00:31:16] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well, look, something big could happen. I do not want to rush to judgment about who is liable to push us in the direction of something big happening. I think we're being sold a bill of goods with respect to who the boogeymen are and that it's a distraction. But in any case, maybe we should get to the topic at hand. I will say. What should I say? Let me say that I think people may be surprised at where I'm not entirely sure where you are on this topic at the moment. I know that my position has changed somewhat over time. But in any case, you and I do not find ourselves in exactly the same place. And I think people would be interested to know that we actually find ourselves maybe reversed from where people would expect us. You as a Holocaust scholar who spent 20 years looking in detail at the Holocaust have, I think you have certain sympathies that have worn thin with me.

[00:32:40] Dr. Bret Weinstein: And I, as a Jewish person who grew up in a secular Jewish home, am now quite troubled by the predicament not only that Israel finds itself in, but that Israel seems to be putting Jews in the diaspora in. And I'm looking for a way out. I feel like I'm being, you know, sucked down in a whirlpool and I'm struggling to escape it. A whirlpool that is not of my making. And I know that I'm not alone. The private conversations that are being had amongst many Jews in the diaspora, I think would be very surprising to non-Jews. I don't know if they would be surprising to Israelis, but there's something to be discussed here. And I don't want people to leap to a judgment about, you know, who's where. The purpose of this discussion is for you and me to talk in real time without guardrails about what we think. And why so people can hear what good hearted people who, frankly, are involved.

[00:33:52] Dr. Bret Weinstein: This is the thing I should have said. You and I are committed to the idea that by ignoring the evolutionary component of genocide, the evolutionary analysis of that historical process, we have eliminated the tool that is most likely to be able to banish that pattern forever. In other words, we've blinded ourselves to what genocide is. We tell ourselves certain comforting stories about how that process unfolds. It's the result of monsters who lose their minds. And because we don't understand how, frankly, natural that process is, we can't figure out how to make good on the promise to never let it happen again. So you and I are betting and with an analysis that I think is very compelling, that our best tool is to understand genocide in an unflinching, analytically rigorous way. And the purpose for doing that includes maybe most importantly, our ability to spot genocides when they happen and to or to when they are about to happen and to prevent them from being carried through on.

[00:35:09] Dr. Bret Weinstein: So that's that's where we proceed from. You and I are in complete agreement about that much. Am I is that fair to say?

[00:35:15] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Absolutely. Yeah. Obviously, we've been, you know, first and foremost, you're a friend, but we also have a working relationship and which began in it's been over six years now. That was when I first reached out to you and I've just been fleshing out our ideas and, you know, watch this space. We've written something that's that's the crux of it. Yeah, we on this topic, we I think the best way for me is you say things that I wouldn't say and I probably say things that you wouldn't say. But there's a lot of things that we we agree on as well. And, you know, I'd also like to say that, you know, I'm not this isn't my specialism. I'm not representative of the pro, you know, I'm showing my hand here, but I'm not a representative and I wouldn't want to have the responsibility of being the representative of the pro Israeli perspective. But honest, informed people do matter.

[00:36:29] Dr. Jonny Hudson: And, you know, October the seventh. Which I'd like I'd like to, you know, talk about in a moment. The reason that Hamas did October the seventh was to influence not just the decision makers. It was obviously aimed at this. Mass. Reaction from people that know the history, don't know the history that could might leverage their own governments into because we're just so connected.

[00:37:08] Dr. Bret Weinstein: So I need to I need you to fill that in. What do you think Hamas was trying to do?

[00:37:15] Dr. Jonny Hudson: And. They were so, yeah, I had like a bit on like what actually happened on the day, but what so this was this is for me leaping forward a little bit. Well, we have. Information from him himself that says that he was trying to disrupt the normalization process with Saudi Arabia. And this is this is like a it's not the first time this is a pattern. There's been like peace agreements before and then Hamas have launched suicide attacks. But what they were trying to do is get that like, in essence, it's a very, very big question. So I'll try and give the shortest answer I possibly can. They were trying to get footage of their own people being killed by the Israelis. So they knew they weren't trying to. They knew that 5000 people wouldn't be able to attack and then hold a line in Israel or anything like that. They did the most disgraceful and demonic acts imaginable because they knew that Israel would have to respond in a way.

[00:38:35] Dr. Jonny Hudson: And then they went and scuttled into their tunnels and put their women and children above them. The humans, the human shield strategy. And we have more more quotes than we could possibly recite in this podcast of them saying that this is what we're doing, the human shield strategy, and we can see them doing that. They wanted the footage of their own population being murdered or being killed and they will, you know, then they will twist it that it was murdered. They need they wanted that footage, which is I don't think that I don't know if that is even contestable. That was their military aim to get those videos that they could then, you know, break Western hearts with. And then that leverage comes on the government's and then that is I don't know if there's any other interpretation that makes sense to me. That's the short answer to a very big question.

[00:39:32] Dr. Bret Weinstein: OK, let's talk about that answer. I didn't look it up before this podcast, but I tweeted something in the immediate aftermath of October 7th. Something to the effect of. When you think you should do something and your enemy wants you to do the same thing, one of you is miscalculating. So. We are. We are left with. An act by Hamas. That could not help. But induce a. Incredibly vivid reaction from Israel. Hamas wanted it. And Israel wanted it. Or Israel made a mistake. But. What does one make? Look, I. I am. My primary disposition is that I want. To be sympathetic. With Israel. But I would like Israel. To lean into its Western values and not its Old Testament. Values and I have been shocked and disappointed to watch Israel go in exactly the opposite direction. Predictably enough as a result of October 7th and the war in Gaza. I don't know what to do with the fact.

[00:41:24] Dr. Bret Weinstein: That in the aftermath of October 7th. We learn that Benjamin Netanyahu has been. Financially supporting Hamas. I looked up the numbers. And I they're so remarkable I can't even believe they could be correct I question them because they're almost unfathomable. One. To 2 billion dollars. Has gone to Hamas. At various points it's been 35 million dollars a month. That. Raises all kinds of questions. If. If the response to October 7th had been reasonable. I think Benjamin Netanyahu would have been immediately thrown out. Irrespective of what he thought he was doing by supporting Hamas the fact is he both. Supported Hamas massively. And presided over the largest security failure in Israel's history resulting in the largest. Pogrom of Jews since the Holocaust. No matter what was on his mind. A he. Cannot be left in a position to prosecute a war in Gaza.

[00:43:02] Dr. Bret Weinstein: And be we have every right to know how the hell these facts line up. Because you can tell the story. That Hamas wanted the killing of innocents in order to inflame the world. But you can also tell the story that Benjamin Netanyahu wanted an excuse. To. Level Gaza. I think both those stories are. Ghastly. And sensible. That is you can comprehend them and that I don't know what's in Benjamin Netanyahu's mind but I will say I haven't seen a single thing from him that tells me he's anything other than the monster. And. You know Israel's line is we're actually behaving honorably in this war but. Look at who's in charge. It undermines that case immediately.

[00:44:10] Dr. Jonny Hudson: So we can't we we kind of jumped ahead to the interpretation and I wanted to talk about like what exactly what actually happened. Yeah if we could do that and then I do I do I knew that we talk about Netanyahu. So I you know about his support for Hamas which I think is a fantastically interesting topic that should be studied in depth. I don't think it's black and white. But one of the kind of main things that I wanted to speak about today was exactly what happened on October the seventh. Because I after you know the past few months I've been looking into. What went down by the scale the scope of it and it's not going to be in depth but I would like to say a few things because I think it would be like a launch pad for further discussion. So and I think it also gives people maybe some of your audience. Won't know some of this thing these things and it will change their impression on kind of the idea of what Gaza and you know so-called Palestinians are.

[00:45:31] Dr. Jonny Hudson: So I'll try and do this in a few minutes but the lead up to October the seventh. And this is one of the main points that I want to make. In 2018 Hamas started something called the joint room for Palestinian factions and there are thought to be at least 16 different militant factions in Gaza. Just that just that fact alone makes me think of you know all the people that say Gaza is a concentration camp. There is 16 different militant factions in Gaza. You know there's also been over 50 in the last 30 years or 50 billion dollars a low estimate being pumped into that. Not my idea of what a concentration camp is from somebody that does know. So some of these just to look at and these are nine of them. It wasn't just Hamas. You rightly said Hamas launched October the seventh and you know we should think of them as the main instigators. On that day five thousand people crossed into Israel three thousand eight hundred of them were Hamas.

[00:46:49] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Around one thousand two hundred of them were Hamas's Nukhba forces. So these are like their elite of the elite people that have been selected for their ideological fanaticism. But also they're like the Iseng group. Like the Iseng group and of the Hamas and then. There's the Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades, which are the rest of Hamas's forces so three thousand eight hundred. So you've got around two thousand two hundred other fighters some civilians as well. When you look down the line you've got Hamas you've got Palestinian Islamic Jihad. You've got the Popular, Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine General Command. So those two that faction kind of split. So you've got this Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, Popular Resistance Committees and then you've got some ex-Fatah militants.

[00:47:47] Dr. Jonny Hudson: And then you've got the Mujahideen and you've got the Al-Ansa movement. And interestingly when I look at them the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine is a Marxist secular militant organization. So even in the people that you see crossing Israel's border in October the seventh you see this red green alliance. And I think most people know that was surprising to me. So I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of your audience are like what. There were like secular Arabs crossing into Israel on October the seventh. Yes there were. There was this you know this alliance of like genocidal rapists all coming together to murder as many civilians. And they were armed to the teeth as well with very sophisticated weaponry. And you know

[00:48:40] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I can ask a question.

[00:48:42] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah.

[00:48:44] Dr. Bret Weinstein: This has never made sense to me since October 7th. If you just put yourself in the mind of Hamas.

[00:48:58] Dr. Jonny Hudson: OK I'll try.

[00:49:00] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Not hard at this level. You're spilling over the arguably the most guarded border on earth. Into. A territory controlled by arguably the most sophisticated military on earth. I think you have to imagine. Unless something funny is going on. That everybody who spilled over that border. Thought they were not coming home. They thought it was a suicide mission if this story is what we're told it is. Did they. Because the only reason that they got home was the embarrassing. And rather spectacular failure of the Israelis to do what everybody would simply have assumed would have happened which is an immediate overwhelming. Response in which every person who had entered Israel was hunted down and neutralized.

[00:50:12] Dr. Jonny Hudson: So to answer that. Maybe not because this is a plan that you know we think has been made since 2017. I'd like to later talk about what the Israelis knew before the attack. So I think it's and this.

[00:50:30] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Wait wait wait wait wait wait. Let's assume every single thing that we've been told about how we've been told about the Israeli attack. And told about how these people got across the border is true. In what universe is the Israeli response having screwed up and allowed the breach to happen in what universe is the response not immediate and overwhelming.

[00:51:05] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I do I have I have some answers for that. If I you know if I can like if I talk about first of all the extent of the attack I can give some answers as to why there was such a catastrophic response.

[00:51:26] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Okay but but you're your position. Is that Hamas and its partners. Were surprised. That they actually were able to do what they did and many of them return home. They expected to die including the secular folks that you're saying.

[00:51:50] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I would. I would say that. Perhaps to many people the sophistication of their attack was. Like more than you might have it you might expect it wasn't just like a bunch of guys on dirt bikes riding up with wire cutters and the fact that they've had. Almost like what say is like nine years just be mulling over this like how you know how can we how can we do this. And then on top of that you've got catastrophic failures on the other side but you've got you've got a high level. Of of competence of military competence that I don't think is appreciated on the side of the perpetrators here. So there's 119 breaches along the border fence a lot of people like to say oh Israel's built that wall if it was a wall and would see much less and casually figures. And then over that they fired almost only on October the 7th and this is something that the head of the military wing of Hamas boasted on October the 7th site we are firing 5000 rockets.

[00:53:15] Dr. Jonny Hudson: They fired 5000 rockets in one day over at the you know the southern you know that that in the Gaza envelope. Then they started attacking civilian communities and they also simultaneously attacked military bases and they had very sophisticated weapons they had thermobaric grenades that were armed the teeth they were they were ready really ready for this. And then mixed with that you have the the arrogant and they'd also stayed out of earlier rounds like there was around the fighting only months earlier with Palestinian Islamic Jihad and Hamas had stayed out of that. And then Netanyahu's letting this money flow in so they're thinking oh maybe they've got something to lose now that's why they're staying quiet. And and then you've got just catastrophic failures in terms of you know preparedness and listening to people on the ground and being operationally ready for the wild to do the tax from the Israeli sides.

[00:54:26] Dr. Jonny Hudson: It could be that it was just a fucking perfect cluster fuck on the side of the Israelis. The only evidence that we have of course is that it was that massive massive cluster fuck of a very prepared very well armed. Very competent enemy that were embedding themselves in civilian communities murder they weren't if it was a pitch battle between army and army. Then you could send an Apache in and they'd just blast them out you know blast them away but they were going into kibbutzim they were going into moshav they were going into music festivals and they were. And we have testimony from Apache helicopters saying I didn't know if it was. Hamas I didn't know if it was civilian I didn't know who's are like local. Security teams I didn't know whether to shoot or not and we we were just completely unprepared for this low altitude attack when like the weight of evidence does seem to me now.

[00:55:41] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Like it was just this perfect storm of. And. Like if we can talk about. If you want to respond to that because I'd like to talk about. The failures and the what like what Israel knew up to the day as well. But if you want to respond to that first.

[00:56:09] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well it all I mean. I get it but I don't know how many times I've seen this movie where somebody wants something to happen. And the excuse is oh incompetence and then a bunch of people who think they're smart say. Oh never attribute to malice that which can be explained by incompetence but there is no standard ever applied that says yeah incompetence is likely to do this but the level of incompetence we're seeing here has to be deliberate. So I'm not saying that this was deliberate I don't know but I am saying nothing about this. Feels like a normal level of incompetence. For one thing. OK you have the. You're saying Hamas has trained and trained and trained and you know they've got their ducks in a row. But the Israelis withdrew their forces from that border on the anniversary of a famous battle. Leaving the door open. Now if I'm looking at those two facts you've got.

[00:57:30] Dr. Bret Weinstein: An army that has been training for an attack. And the attack comes on a day when the defenses are down. My first question is. Is one of the ways in which Hamas was prepared that they had penetrated the Israeli intelligence services and induced the Israelis to stand down their defenses. But nobody was ever willing to talk about this if the Israelis were decidedly not the least bit interested in figuring out whether or not there was a mole that induced them to. To stand down their weapons so. The fact that they're not even looking is kind of like it smells like O.J. not looking for the real killer of his ex wife it's like.

[00:58:25] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Let me let me strengthen your position here with like and I've just picked how this is what they knew before the attack. The people that gave warnings so. Around six years before October the seventh a detailed assessment was given to Netanyahu a possible large scale assault. From Hamas then in the spring of 2022. We get something tangible it's called the Jericho Wall plan which is about 40 page document that Israeli military intelligence were able to acquire. And it essentially spells out October the seventh so this is spring of 2022 coordinated attack from Gaza on the basis civilian communities. And taking hostages so they obtain this 40 page document in the spring of 2022 then. Ronen Bar who is the head of the time of Shin Bet. Not to be confused with Roseanne Barr. I know they've got a lot of their probably got a lot in common but. So he says that on in July 2023 he was warning Netanyahu this he was dismissed by Netanyahu and now there's a defamation case so that.

[01:00:00] Dr. Jonny Hudson: You know the fighting this out but he says that he warned repeatedly. And the more than the 21st of August about an escalating direction of attacks and usable messages on the 14th of December and one of the first of October that Israel could be drawn into fighting before the end of the holiday period. But it actually gets more than that. So one of the most incredible. Things is that. So there's a division called the well they call Unit 8200. And their official job is like the signals and intelligence unit. But there was an operative there. An analyst there. Three months before so these messages she we know we don't know her name but we know it's a woman we know the first letter of her first name because I'll get on to this later how we know that. But she was saying and we have the messages this was published by the New York Times and it's actually verified by the IDF so we there's no contest in.

[01:01:12] Dr. Jonny Hudson: As to what this happened she said an exercise we observed closely matches the Jericho Wall plan so. The attackers and this is for me this is another right when I think about this i'm thinking about the you know guys as a concentration count constant military drills happening near Israel's border. And they were very sophisticated and Hamas and the you know the joint room used to publish them. On their like Telegram channel and it's like a always like a mock Israeli settlement and they're up there going in and like doing you know very sophisticated military drills. They weren't doing that in concentration camps but anyway i'll go on with I digress so. She tells this to the Gaza Division colonel. This guy needs locking up if he's not already and he says exercise is based on totally imaginative scenario and then he goes on this is direct quote in short let's wait patiently.

[01:02:31] Dr. Jonny Hudson: So she said like I know the Jericho Wall plan I've just I can see them practicing it like what is the point in having her in this position. Like let's go on a bit before I conclude like that then she says back. Direct quote. And this is further from July we don't have an exact date for this, but this is all leading up by the last message you said and this is like very close October the 7th she said history may repeat itself if we are not careful. And then she's ignored again and then with reference I think this is like a like a biblical reference and this is supposed to be in the like even in the days before October the 7th she says the sword is coming down so she's. She knows Jericho Wall she's watching these military exercises can you imagine being that person. Like and then October the 7th happens she's called — the IDF actually confirmed this and she's called Vav.

[01:03:41] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Apparently maybe in Hebrew that's how you pronounce the first syllable or the first letter of her name and it failed to reach senior officials, so this Gaza, Gaza Division colonel. Did not like she was saying this to him and he didn't even bother to pass it on, although she's reporting this for months and you know what you know what she got in the end. And the IDF chief, Eyal Zamir, presented her with a certification of appreciation and military conference on the 4th October 2026 for recognizing. For having raised the warning before the attack. So she got a certificate. So she's there on.

[01:04:37] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Look let's just be. Honest about this it's very hard to evaluate from the outside whether or not it's unusual for a prescient warning to be ignored because we have no idea how many warnings there are that amount to nothing. We can't calibrate our shock but what you said is completely shocking and consistent with a bunch of other facts that suggest more than a normal security failure. Again so much by way of security failures that my first question. If I were in Netanyahu shoes would be did something get into our system. And aid the invaders. But they're not interested in that question. Why not.

[01:05:41] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I don't I the one thing that we agree on and I want to talk about one thing just before the one thing that we agree on I do want to because this I just find this so so tragic and they deserve to be remembered the young female idea surveillance soldiers. So their job is there by late teens early 20s their job is in a base called Nahal house is to watch the enemy activity. And we have all sorts of evidence of them just reporting to that like it's not we know that it isn't like just more of the same because it's unusual activity and. For example one called Roni Lifshitz says that just. Days beforehand 10 pickup trucks and 300 300 meters away and there was just like people examining and pointing towards Israeli cameras and gates and fence so they weren't being that sly about it were they. Say seems really reckless if you if you're planning this mass invasion why why are you just doing that to me that doesn't make sense.

[01:07:03] Dr. Jonny Hudson: And but there's just more testimony from these from these girls. One thing that bugs me is that I've. I've been to Israel know I've been. And I remember just seeing I off duty reservists on the beach like just dressed in normal clothes. I sometimes in like in swim dress and they were carrying their guns with them is obviously something you're going to notice if you're a British person because you're not used to being around guns. Why weren't these girls armed like they were unarmed and then Hamas came and slaughtered 16 of them they weren't even able to go down by with a fight why why. Were these people on the beach on to the teeth in their swimsuits and then. These girls were just and then they were just completely ignored and you know the surviving members. Say that they think it was because they were junior what's the point in having them in that post they're telling you.

[01:08:15] Dr. Jonny Hudson: There's more testimony than I could I can be bothered reading here, but it is. Extensive and significant they're saying this they're not just saying it's more of the same they're saying that this is really really unusual and this is in the days before and then 16 of them if I was their parents. I would be incandescent really I would on many different levels but they were warning against this and you can see the text where they're joking like all it be your shift on my shift. But the fact that they got slaughtered like that after having said it's something weird happening and then you hadn't armed them even though. And apparently they are getting armed now but. It just it makes me pissed off that like even now I'm actually quite pissed off now thinking about that.

[01:09:15] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well, I mean pissed off is one thing but. The problem with the story is it just does not stand up to scrutiny and the thing that stands up least well is. Netanyahu who. No matter where you stand. This is a villain of October 7. I mean for one thing let's say that your point is simply Hamas are but barbarians they. slaughtered. A thousand ish or more people we can talk about what the actual number is some later point but let's say your point is look Hamas are are just simply animals who. Let's say that they're they're rabid animals who did what rabid animals do to innocent civilians in Israel. And you might say look the Palestinians are. Complicit because they've elected Hamas. Right it still doesn't account for the children who presumably by any Western framework are innocent but let's just say we buy the maximum amount of guilt for the Palestinians and.

[01:10:45] Dr. Bret Weinstein: The story becomes simple they've elected Hamas and Hamas has done. A terrifying atrocity that has inflamed the Israelis who are being as. Careful as possible in their attempt to ferret them out in Gaza let's just say that that's all the case.

[01:11:05] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Just do remember it wasn't just a massive was it was nine other armed groups and then there was about two five maybe two to five hundred civilians then got involved and the place as well.

[01:11:15] Dr. Bret Weinstein: OK fair enough but let's just say all of that is simple and straightforward. How. It seems to me that Benjamin Netanyahu. Is responsible. For feeding Hamas to the Palestinians. He's giving them huge amounts of money. So their success is in part because the prime minister of Israel wanted them to succeed. Now there's a explanation for why he would have wanted them to succeed which is to divide the Palestinians so they would not unify under the Palestinian authority. But OK let's say that he was cynical as the story goes and that he was. Funding Hamas for those cynical reasons because he wanted. To hobble the Palestinians. How is he how is he not in the end responsible for whatever. Guilt you might assign to Palestinian adults for electing Hamas. You know. I don't get it. This guy. Is all over this story and even if we give him. A hundred percent of the benefit of the doubt and then give him a budget 50 percent beyond that.

[01:12:59] Dr. Bret Weinstein: He's still. Responsible for October 7th at many different levels. And it is not surprising that leaving him as the spokesman for Israel and the person in charge of presiding over the military campaign in Gaza has been. Pissed off the world. It certainly pissed me off if the Israelis had fired him and said now we have a difficult problem we have to figure out what to do in Gaza and unfortunately Hamas is using. Civilians as human shields which means we are going to end up killing innocent people and the world is going to see it if they had. Gotten rid of Netanyahu and then. Made it clear that they were forced to do things that they didn't want to do they were trying their best I would be listening. But having left the man in charge the man who created the I mean you know I I hesitate to bring it up here but somehow. This guy is the Anthony Fauci of October 7th right Anthony Fauci is responsible for creating COVID Through gain of function research which got offshored as a result of the Obama era ban to the Wuhan Institute so he's right there at the creation of the problem and then he's the guy in charge of watching the response that's the same thing as Benjamin Netanyahu.

[01:14:39] Dr. Bret Weinstein: These people are heralded as heroes but they are the demons of the stories in question. Getting out of these predicaments involves getting rid of those people and putting honorable intelligent people in charge of cleaning up the mess as soon as you spot it and not doing it. We are. I think we're just absolutely. Justified in being. Concerned that we don't know what actually explains any of this the anomalies are too many.

[01:15:18] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah I think this this might be. Like our point of most agreement but also perhaps most disagreement as well and I'll. I'll explain why with so people in terms of high level people who were sacked or resigned so we have in April 2024 we have Aharon Haliva, head of IDF military intelligence resigned June 2024 Avi Rosenfeld, Gaza Division commander resigned. September 2020 so all within a year you'll see Sariel, commander of the unit 8200 signals and intelligence unit resigned and then within the next half of the year we see for the IDF chief of staff, the Southern Command chief we see him fall. Herzi Halevi and then we see Haim Cohen, commander in chief of the Gaza Division's Northern Brigade, he resigned and then. Ronen Bar, remember, not Roseanne Barr and Shin Bet director he he announces his resignation because Netanyahu is about to sack him.

[01:16:35] Dr. Jonny Hudson: So Netanyahu's in terms of the. Level of authority he's the only one standing there are there are other people as well that were that should have been sacked or resigned that haven't that he really is the only one and he's probably he's never made a decent apology. Maybe he's made a bit of apology in English but apparently never in Hebrew don't know what that means but it's probably symbolic in some way we absolutely agree just in terms of common sense that he should if he had. Like any any self respect any dignity. He should step down because why why should the the basic. morals and. Situations that apply to all of us like if you completely fuck up that much then you like in in any of the jobs I've had or any of the relationships I've ever had in my life if I fuck up that badly then I apologize profusely. And if I have got response you know if it was something that I and then I would just step down I would or I'd be fired.

[01:18:05] Dr. Jonny Hudson: By in any normal situation to fuck up that badly. You you go you go I don't see him as the demon that you see him I just. I personally. I haven't seen the evidence.

[01:18:24] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I see him as a demon again and again in fact in every context he seems to be. I don't know what to make of his. description of Israel fighting an eight front war where the eighth front is Rome and then he periodically says the US is Rome I don't know what that is am I seeing. edits of things that don't belong together somehow maybe. I see he's got. A mRNA COVID vaccine syringe memorialized on his desk. After participating in the mass vaccination of the Israeli population which because I'm a COVID dissident who knows about those shots I know that this is something to be ashamed of and nothing to be proud of and yet he remains apparently proud of it. I know that he destroyed a warehouse of hydroxychloroquine as COVID approached and that that warehouse of hydroxychloroquine chloroquine might have alleviated a great deal of suffering. I watch him cynically.

[01:19:33] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Funding Hamas with what I still frankly think are unthinkable amounts of money and then blaming the Palestinians for electing these people that he has propped up. I see him presiding over the botching of Israeli border security in a way that cost 1000 Israelis more than 1000 Israelis their lives I see. him. Portraying what are supposed to be facts of the October 7th attacks. falsely in a way that. Will predictably cause the Israeli public to. thirst for blood.

[01:20:20] Dr. Jonny Hudson: All the other ones I don't know if he if he they I don't know if he can actually pin that one on him in terms of the exaggeration there was. All of the other things yes, but. Actually, if you look at the evidence in terms of exaggerating the extent of October the 7th. What you find is you know the the 40 like the beheaded babies thing that was an Israeli news outlet. And Israeli hidden any answers spokesman did say that like a baby had or people have been beheaded including babies and then you do have. Like a like one of the forensic medics saying yeah that were amongst. People that were like the head babies had been beheaded but we did we it doesn't we don't know if it was through explosion or. Very fucking dark shit that we don't know if it's through explosion or deliberate beheading.

[01:21:28] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well, I looked into it a little bit I think we down now do know that babies were not beheaded that that was a false story. Do you disagree.

[01:21:41] Dr. Jonny Hudson: So I would say. No I'd say that like Dr. Chen Kugel director of Israel's National Center of forensic medicine. Said that. To The Media Line, bodies including babies were without heads. So unless he's lying. Then you know. That that's that's the person that I would trust and I wouldn't be surprised by what they went and did that they were using thermobaric grenades they were using all sorts of weapons and. There was attacking civilian communities the 40 babies things obviously bullshit but that income but no.

[01:22:35] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Okay, so what did his spokesman say.

[01:22:41] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Just confirmed that the beheadings including children are taking place. So so wait a second.

[01:22:49] Dr. Bret Weinstein: That does sound like official lying. About atrocities.

[01:22:56] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I'd have to look at exactly

[01:22:58] Dr. Bret Weinstein: beheading suggests intentional. Decapitations might not.

[01:23:06] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah. So this is the chaos of a mass atrocity as well so I yeah.

[01:23:17] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I must tell you of all of the anomalous facts lying about atrocities after atrocities have been committed against you gives me chills. I know it tells me I don't know something. Right somebody who wished. Somebody who wanted the reaction to October 7 would have an interest in exaggerating October 7 which frankly doesn't need any exaggeration. Terrifying enough.

[01:23:49] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah I would also say that we when somebody when a when a nation when a people have just been attacked in such a way then. You know we have to give them some good grace that they might be getting some of the facts wrong and they're not very clear headed in the days.

[01:24:10] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Look there's a different there's a difference between initial reports always being wrong. And lies. And. I'm sorry for me. That is a bright red line. That is a bright red line this did not need any exaggeration whatsoever. And to exaggerate it not only is it unforgivable but it cannot help but call into question what we think we know about this event. If I know that you're lying I don't trust your testimony at all. And so at the point that we're dealing with questions of what I think are implausible failures of intelligence and security. To discover that there are lies about harms that. We are being told. That the most innocent Israelis. Were brutally beheaded. By these. Hamas militants. Look you're you're a genocide scholar. You know exactly what that's going to do in the minds of people who hear it. I mean yeah frankly I was skeptical of this.

[01:25:47] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Security failure from the beginning. But I bought that shit. They lied to me they they manipulated me and I'm pissed. I didn't need to be manipulated. I was perfectly capable of being horrified by something horrifying. To exaggerate it now puts me in. A terrible position trying to evaluate what actually happened. What kind of.

[01:26:18] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Monster did have to be the 40 babies thing is just it's just crazy because why would 40 babies be in the same place and I would you know it's just.

[01:26:28] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well I mean listen when you hear that 40 babies were beheaded what it suggests is that must have been the plan. Let's find some babies and behead them.

[01:26:40] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I can't remember ever believing that though I just. Ever caught wind of it at the time. But yeah but what it does it does disgrace the memory of the actual victims as well because then people they have. A leverage to say actually no you know you're the victims didn't actually you know look at this is both your property under you know the numbers were much lower than actually where and you know.

[01:27:15] Dr. Bret Weinstein: That lie takes the credibility of every person who propagated it. Probably the public.

[01:27:26] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah, but I will have to stress that the 40 babies thing came from an Israeli news outlet and then then Netanyahu's spokesman like in the well in the heat said that yes some people have been beheaded including babies and we don't know and then the forensic medical. It said we don't know if it was due to beheading or or explosion so it was I don't think it's.

[01:27:52] Dr. Bret Weinstein: It sounds like the usual garbage where you tell a lie knowing that you're going to have to back it off because you know that the lie will propagate much more effectively than your correction.

[01:28:09] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah who were whoever's involved in in that. It disservice to the actual victims October the 7th.

[01:28:21] Dr. Bret Weinstein: And if I could whatever whatever else may be true it sounds like the prime minister's office did not immediately correct the story.

[01:28:31] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah, I would I would I would tend to want to give them some grace though in the aftermath of October the 7th like this with these were in the days after and they are human beings as well. And the way that the jihadists and these genocide gangs attacked their country. I would want to give these people a little bit of grace to you know even they got no.

[01:28:57] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Long look you can do that. I am not giving grace to anybody who knew better. It's one thing if somebody repeats a lie that they've been told not having questioned it it is another thing for anybody. To spread notorious lies. At a moment when the mind is trying to formulate an understanding of what has happened and what needs to be done about it what its implications are. And. And I will tell you look. This is all just so terrifying and awful but. From the point of somebody point of view of somebody who wanted. The excuse of October 7th. Exaggerating atrocities would be perfectly in keeping that's the problem. You've got an unthinkable failure of security that raises the question which look you can think I'm a crazy person for saying it. But you heard Charlie Kirk ask in very plain terms on the Patrick Bet-David podcast. What he saw being well versed having spent lots of time in Israel what he saw made him think maybe there was a stand-down order he wanted to know and.

[01:30:31] Dr. Bret Weinstein: In light of security failures great enough. To make Charlie Kirk wonder if there might be more to it to introduce lies about atrocities. No no no this is just monstrous behavior. Unforgivable anybody who knowingly lied about that unforgivable.

[01:30:56] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Oh knowingly lied yeah but. People. I can't imagine what it's like when you've had. You know a genocidal attack on your country. Looks like that Jonny. A music has been attacked and people that went out to dance have just been three hundred and seventy of them have been slaughtered. And you just trying to make. You just want to use all this information flying around I know that they should have done better but I get it I'm I don't I don't know if I had the scenario. I'm just trying to. Comprehend the opposite to what you're saying I don't know how to make two ways of it either.

[01:31:47] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Jonny look. I actually as as your friend have to ask for forgiveness in advance for the thought experiment I'm about to confront you with. Okay. No it's terrible. But I want you to imagine. That something has happened to one of your children. Can you. Possibly imagine lying about the extent of it. In my case I it's the. The thought is repulsive I can't I can't imagine. I can't imagine doing that and I don't think that just because October 7th was. Terrifying and traumatic that we should expect. Anyone to have. Lied in some way that we have to forgive I think people who lie in such circumstances are. Inherently vile.

[01:32:59] Dr. Jonny Hudson: He obviously yeah with with the if it was intentional lies. It's. Just mentioned it's just beyond awful because in the preparation for this podcast I've been reading off about the actual victims individuals October the 7th and it to lie it desecrates their memory. But the point. That I'm making is. Do. Do we know that these were intentional lies and I've never I've never had a genocidal or a murderous attack on myself or my community or my country and then just been having to pick up the pieces in the aftermath and then all this information is flowing from here to there. So if it was if we know that they were lying then I'm going to condemn it as much as you. But I also. I'm not saying that it was this but I want to raise the question that. In the aftermath of a you know an attack by genocidal rapists that. Almost obliterated entire kibbutz in and raped and murdered hundreds of people at music festival that the bloodshed and the information.

[01:34:34] Dr. Jonny Hudson: And disparity that might have been mistakes made in the heat of the moment in the days. Following the attack. I'm I don't want to be in it I don't want I don't want to put myself I don't want to be like oh yeah I'm defending this these are questions that I'm asking.

[01:34:54] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well I think you know the prime minister's office not having shut down what it must have known was a falsehood is telling I also in looking into the state of the evidence in twenty twenty six find that the claims of rape were exaggerated. I don't know what the truth was but. The idea this was portrayed as systematic raping. I think the evidence does not support that. So I also find that just like the killing of innocents, the raping of young women is. Reliably except in the case of grooming gangs in Britain I guess but reliably with normal people absolutely inflammatory. So if you wanted. To whip a population into a genocidal frenzy. These are the kind of lies you would tell.

[01:36:03] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I haven't I haven't heard any over exaggerations in terms of I've heard. Rape testimony or numbers of rapes. That have been unbelievable I don't know what you've heard but I've heard I've got one here. Yoni Saadon who was who was 39 at the time. So he was he was at the Nova festival. Hidden the bodies of the deceased. And he says that he witnessed a woman being beaten and raped by eight to ten. Hamas fighters and she pleaded them to stop and then quote when they finished they were laughing. And the last one shot her in the head. So. Like for him to come forward and say yeah put my name on that. And then there's been a separate UN inquiry of how many of the deceased women were found. Which is that they. And like necrophilia basically or we don't know if they're being raped before or after they'd been murdered but obviously a lot of these women.

[01:37:26] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Like were aren't alive to tell their testimony. So I haven't an exaggeration of the rape would be typical of. Whipping whipping up. But I haven't seen like. Perhaps what you've seen I've seen like a UN inquiry and then just individual testimony like this.

[01:37:53] Dr. Bret Weinstein: What I've seen is the claim that independent investigations. Failed to find. A systematic pattern of rape I think it is not understood by anybody to be zero. But again the. Impression of an enemy that stormed across the border with this as part of the plan. Is. It cannot help but persuade a population that. I mean look. You're a genocide scholar. You know that lying to people is. How you get them to be complicit in. The violent displacement of. Non kin. So all I'm saying is I don't know what happened here I'm obviously remote from the actual facts. But the fact that there are lies here at all bothers me greatly.

[01:39:03] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah I don't I don't know what it's like to be a genocidal rapist either because. You break you know they had control of the Nova site for example just take one site for four and a half hours and we'll you know we're talking about response time. As well which we haven't really gone into as well which is obviously unfathomable that they. There is actually some evidence that says that the police in the military thought that each of them had no recovered so they didn't. I think you know maybe that's for another time but it's just unthinkable that four and a half hours can imagine the hell that transpired when. Hamas had the Nova festival site in control for four and a half hours they were just like maybe that is enough time to rape. I don't know what I going on a genocide or rampage does to your libido there's probably a bit of science behind that.

[01:40:06] Dr. Jonny Hudson: That's the thing that I don't know because it seems a bit weird that you'd be on a genocidal rampage and then you'd be committing rape at the same time. You know the rape that the Nazis did they had control of the areas they were using the women as sex slaves. It wasn't in my in the spread of maybe an enemy so that's that's something I don't know. Yeah there was a

[01:40:29] Dr. Bret Weinstein: lot of there was a lot of. Nazi raping of vulnerable people.

[01:40:40] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah but not whilst they were like in the throes of combat not to my knowledge.

[01:40:49] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I mean there aren't a lot of women in combat or weren't. Nonetheless as long as we're on this very uncomfortable topic there does seem to be quite a bit of evidence of the IDF behaving. Well. Raping and sexually assaulting. Palestinian. Women in Gaza. You see that too.

[01:41:23] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I haven't know I would be surprised if. Yeah to be surprised if that was the case. Why. Just. It would just be such an incredibly damaging thing to do if you cared about your country by knowing. Knowing that the other side is. Basically initiated a genocidal assault on you so they can get video footage and propaganda. That they can use to disgrace and incite violence against Jewish people if you then. Gave the enemy that then. I just like would would you how could you even. Like you must have a family back in Israel what you're going and doing that you're going giving the enemy exactly what they want you making you making the libel true. I just can't imagine this. Not such monstrous behavior but such reckless behavior.

[01:42:41] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I don't know I got to tell you. We are all stuck in a terrifying situation where our access to information is. Interfered with by algorithms and who knows what drives them. But I believe I have seen. Compelling. Testimony of that. Doesn't surprise me terribly but the other thing Jonny is that you and I both know. That the thing that sets genocide apart from. Regular war. As ghastly as that may be. Is the deliberate targeting of children. And the reason for that is. Because if you're trying to displace a population then the innocence of children is irrelevant because children. Are the future of the population you're displacing. So. Again. The questions coming out of Gaza are. I think. Beyond terrifying. We have doctors saying that the pattern of injuries that they're seeing children are consistent with deliberate targeting. Is it possible that those doctors are lying I guess.

[01:44:29] Dr. Bret Weinstein: But. You know I also will tell you I look at the. Trump administration's and their mock ups their. Illustrations of the renewed rebuilt Gaza that they want to bring to the world. And I think wait a minute. You telling me that you want to the middle of a conflict you're telling me that you want to rebuild this place with these. Gleaming skyscraper towers on the beach. Are you doing that for the Palestinians. Or are you admitting. That actually the Palestinians. Have lost this territory as a result of this conflict. And that you're taking it over in other words when I look at those images either I have a paradox which is that in the midst of a conflict. The United States is. Thinking about rebuilding. The structures in a marvelously modern form. For. A population that. Israel detests. You would think that would cause friction between. Our countries unless of course those images are actually a tacit admission of at least ethnic cleansing.

[01:45:59] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I mean am I wrong.

[01:46:05] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Perhaps Trump's just trying to move the Overton window a bit because what's happened over the last 70 years is just isn't working. The Israelis tried to move out in 2005. There you go. There's a territory. We've tried not we've tried the Israelis have tried to make. There's been many many. You know our thoughts walked away from deals. Like do you want to stay on not. And it like the whole idea of Palestinianism is predicated on the destruction of Israel. They do not want to stay. They do not want an end to the. All everything that they've they've there's been over 50 billion dollars pumped into that territory. And I mean just Gaza. Over the last 30 years and they've built an acropolis like a base to like perpetrate genocide. And this is this is just like literally what I see. So you know what. Trump's mad plan. Maybe he's just trying to move the Overton window to let's not just keep on giving like the.

[01:47:18] Dr. Jonny Hudson: The genocide is a fresh start again because you don't get a fresh start. You don't just keep on attacking and then losing and then saying OK let's let's broker another deal. It's not working. And you know. Do do. I I am unsure whether or not. We I don't know. I don't even know what the word Palestinian or Palestine means. I don't even know if we should. If it's helpful to keep up. Like what is a Palestinian. What is Palestine. Is that not just propaganda. That was created in essence to destroy the state of Israel. If not why they keep on walking away from these deals. Why does that be heavy fear. They don't want to stay. They don't want a territory alongside Israel. They they want Israel to disappear by one means or another. I don't I don't see anything that's telling me that.

[01:48:29] Dr. Bret Weinstein: OK. I think that's a good summation of your position. I will tell you there are still people who talk to me and I'm about to lay out my position which probably will drive off every last one because nobody's going to like it. Here's what I see. OK. And you know I'm not telling you anything. You don't know you and I have been working from this model for a long time. And my long time. Viewers and listeners will be familiar with pieces of it too. There are two bases that you can build a civilization on. One of them is kinetic kinship. The other is reciprocity. The West is based on reciprocity. We're supposed to ignore kinship and collaborate because it makes us all wealthier when we do productive things and you do less productive things if you're limited to collaborating with people who are kin. So reciprocity the West is way better. It's just a better system.

[01:49:50] Dr. Bret Weinstein: The problem is it's fragile and it breaks down into lineage against lineage violence. It breaks down into blood is thicker than water. So if I'm to give the hardliners there do they might say hey Bret you love the West but you don't understand it's a fiction because it works in good times and it falls apart in bad times and you can't stop bad times from happening. So we're condemned to the blood is thicker than water version of human collaboration. I disagree with them but we'll put that off for another day. The problem is Israel if we rewind the tape prior to October 7th I would say Israel is a nation with one foot in the West and one foot in the West. One foot in the Torah. And the problem is Israel is surrounded by hostile neighbors which pulls it in the direction of the Torah and it is participating in global commerce innovation technology in a way that pushes it toward the West and it has Western values on the ground.

[01:51:07] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I'm led to understand. I haven't seen it myself but it's a modern Western state in terms of its internal day to day function. All of that said. I think the hardliners on both sides if you look at the Middle East you've got Jews and you've got Muslims and obviously just as with Jews you have different lineages you have different lineages of Muslims but by and large you have these two overarching factions and I think both of them. Coming from their ancient roots. Are proceeding from rules that say. There isn't an alternative to genocide. You drive a population out and you survive or it drives you out and they survive. Anything else is fairy tales. And so. The reason I think that you're seeing on the Islamic side of the line what you've just described where. You have people who. Seem to walk away from the opportunity at making peace because in their minds they need their competitor to disappear.

[01:52:49] Dr. Bret Weinstein: That's a primitive mindset that's pre-Western. And it's not it's brutal. But it's not irrational. If you knew that in the Middle East only one of these two factions was going to exist 500 years from now you'd behave very differently in the present because there's no point in a temporary peace especially if it causes you to lay down your arms and become vulnerable. So here's why I'm going to lose all of my remaining friends over my perspective. I am horrified by. Israel's behavior. Relative to October 7. I want Israel to lean into its western side and I see it leaning into exactly the opposite. But I'm not wildly sympathetic to the Palestinians either and I see. I see my intellectual compatriots making this mistake which is they want to stand with whoever the current victim is and they don't want to be in the same place. I recognize the dynamic that allows current victim status to move between populations indefinitely.

[01:54:16] Dr. Bret Weinstein: In other words I stand with every single person who is against genocidal behavior with every actually innocent person. I don't hold people responsible for the sins of their ancestors. Children who are born in Gaza are innocent by definition because I have a western mindset. They are not future terrorists. They are undefined. They are innocent. But the point is look the two teams are not the Israelis and the Muslims. The two teams are those of us who are against genocide and those of us who think it's the only way. And I don't know how to make that resonate for people so that they actually look at the Middle East differently and they say oh my God we're playing out a you know a death spiral. That will threaten to drag the entire world into it. We may actually be looking at the fate of humanity. Instead people say hey those people are strong and these people are weak and being genocidal rather than yeah actually if the tables turned if who was strong and who was weak was inverted you'd see exactly the inverse puzzle.

[01:55:39] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Right. So how I mean look you are as well positioned as anyone on earth to evaluate what I've just said. You know what I'm talking about because we've been through this material. Am I making sense or have I lost my mind.

[01:56:01] Dr. Jonny Hudson: You're making absolute sense. I think the big difference is that you can see genocidal behavior in Israel's reaction to October the 7th and I just can't see. I just in my in my estimation my understanding of what genocide and genocide and genocidal intent is. There's never ever a defensive element to it. And the demonic tactics of their enemy as well. We've never seen I I've never seen a territory as genocidal as Gaza and I'm not condemning you know the innocents to you know the war that their leaders have dragged them into. But for me as a somebody that understands genocide. This this is something that I've never never witnessed before the Nazis at the end they were Hitler was like okay everybody's got to go. They never led with let's let's get our own civilians murdered and let's let's initiate attack. So and then let's bury ourselves underground and and get the women and the kids killed.

[01:57:34] Dr. Jonny Hudson: And you know and the behavior on October the 7th and the charter and all of that and then all of the money that's poured in as well and all I've done is like built a necropolis. It's for me the most genocidal territory space regime. I don't want to want to want to you know I know that a lot of them are children as well that you know you're not genocidal when you're a child but UNRWA is it's a mechanism for genocide because what you're telling people is this is not your home. And and when you look at some of the kids shows you know all of the evidence I'm not cherry picking so it's like hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of hours of evidence that I've seen and this. This this place is something different and you know how else are Israel supposed to respond to this because if they show any week. Go ahead. If they if they like this is this is if you if you look at like the Middle East you've got you know what is it 500 million Arabs and then you've got literally the thorn in their side is Israel.

[01:58:55] Dr. Jonny Hudson: It's you know all of these armed groups that are on Israel's border are funded by Iran. Are they supposed to what they supposed to do show do nothing. Because that will and this is the reason that like I probably see Netanyahu while I definitely see I would have talked about Netanyahu in the same terms that you do. I just don't see that in I just see like you see impossible job to try and steer the Jewish people into a place where they will still exist and make sure the walls don't don't consume them again and you know with all this you know Hamas support thing you know it's a valid point there.

[01:59:47] Dr. Bret Weinstein: All right I have a couple things I want to say. You said this war that the Palestinians leaders have dragged them into. I don't understand how we separate that from Israel's leaders having dragged them into it to. Given the financial support that Netanyahu has facilitated going to them. In other words if you're going to fault the leadership of the Palestinians which I think you should I don't see how you escape faulting the leadership of the Israelis and if they had thrown Netanyahu out you could say they made mistakes and learn from them but having not thrown him out it seems to me that you have to draw that boundary fairly.

[02:00:38] Dr. Jonny Hudson: What Netanyahu dragged what into the fourth into the war after October 7th I mean they should have that's that's the one thing that we agree on that they should have he should have resigned or they should have dragged him out.

[02:00:52] Dr. Bret Weinstein: No no my point is Benjamin Netanyahu cynically dragged the Palestinians into alignment with Hamas by giving Hamas huge amounts of money. Okay

[02:01:07] Dr. Jonny Hudson: so the Hamas Hamas support.

[02:01:09] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Yeah I mean look in my country we in 2011 passed the NDAA of 2012 which literally defined any person who supported a terrorist organization as a terrorist that we were entitled to pull off any street in the world and not acknowledge that we had literally take them to a black site and not not acknowledge that we'd even taken them in the world. And they're not going to be able to get into custody. Now a federal court ruled that a journalist might reasonably fear that provision if they had so much as talked to a terrorist organization in the process of doing journalism. Benjamin Netanyahu actually supported with millions of dollars it sounds like if I'm reading the evidence correctly over the entire course of his facilitation a billion to $2 billion were conducted to these people this guy is materially supporting the exact terrorists. That instigated October 7th.

[02:02:20] Dr. Bret Weinstein: No matter what that was it's it's ghastly and unthinkable.

[02:02:25] Dr. Jonny Hudson: It's ghastly and unthinkable but so I'll yeah so from 2012 he helped facilitate Qatari assistance to Gaza and this amounted to a lot of money. And the intelligence estimates like put it roughly. At some times actually going directly to Hamas's armed wing Israeli intelligence were telling him you know Roseanne Barr who I talked about earlier. She he was telling him that this isn't actually going to civilian works projects this is actually being funneled straight into. Hamas's armed wing but I actually don't think that there's a difference. Like whether or not you know if it's going to mass my position is it doesn't matter if it's like we can we can trace the funds going straight to paying the the terrorists wages or if it's going to civilian works projects or it's going to

[02:03:38] Dr. Bret Weinstein: or it's going to their or it's going to their political campaigns. The Israelis are holding the Palestinians responsible for their own fate because they chose Hamas but their leader chose to give Hamas money which undoubtedly. Allowed them to portray themselves in a sympathetic light to the people who elected them.

[02:04:03] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah I have here like so it's thought that four million a month was going to the al-Qassam Brigades during 2019 to 2021 which is like 50% and that's you know directly being facilitated by Israel. So all of what you said is completely true like Netanyahu's argument is a bad one. I think I've got a better one for him. He said that he says economic relief would give Hamas something to lose from renewed fighting. I just I just see this you know he's this this game of chess that he's trying to play and although what he's done there is a complete fuck up. He should resign for that alone. And then you put on you know you put on top of that know the. The fact that they weren't prepared at all for a low altitude attack and the response to the attack as well. So I think there's three reasons there why he should resign in a second. But also just like the reason that he's trying to play this house of cards.

[02:05:23] Dr. Jonny Hudson: This is the most forgiving interpretation of this. It's like think about what it must be like to be him and trying to you know steer the Jewish state. You know through the next day through the next year and he's taken this gamble on just like this horrendous. This you know with the benefit of high sight stupid gamble on trying to play Hamas off against the Palestinian Authority and you know down you know underestimating the strength of Hamas.

[02:05:58] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I think you're making a classic mistake. I think you're. And for anybody who hears this strangely I define sympathy and empathy in a very specific way but I think you're. You are attempting to empathize with a psychopath. With a psychopath. I think this person is a psychopath and you because you're not one are misunderstanding you're having a failure of theory of mind because you're really dealing with a very different kind of creature. Right. And so this idea of like well what must it be like. Well I don't know psychopaths are. They gamble willingly they get bored without the thrill of it. They are completely indifferent to the suffering of. And I think if you if you imagine. That the evidence points to that in Netanyahu's case. That everything gets much simpler and many other possibilities that you need to have on the table become. Become obviously salient.

[02:07:17] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I'm not saying I know that he is one I don't know I'm not an expert but I will say that the pattern. Of this particular hardliner and his behavior at least fits loosely all of the characteristics that you would expect.

[02:07:34] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah I do you know what I do. I was thinking earlier today I must be crazy being Netanyahu. Imagine being that because he I for me in my estimation he's the most hated person on the planet right now. I don't think there's a close second. Imagine just being that I just want that must. What must that do to a human mind. This amount of power. Also like being in that position and just. I don't really have anything to say off the back of that. It just fascinates me what it you know. How would you even go to sleep.

[02:08:16] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Just with all exactly what if you were a normal person in his shoes you wouldn't be able to sleep.

[02:08:23] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah.

[02:08:24] Dr. Bret Weinstein: All right I wanted to add a couple more things in here. Okay. You said if I understood you correctly. That there is never a defensive component. In genocide. Now I don't have the

[02:08:48] Dr. Jonny Hudson: legitimate defense defensive component.

[02:08:54] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I don't know how to process that because.

[02:08:57] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Because it's always it's always made up always pitched by it's always pitched as. Yeah there's always been. Genocide is like all the sub subalternate subalternate by this and there's a name for it where it's like to get in them back or getting them first. Every genocide is is is kind of that but it's. Fantasy the reason for it. Okay. Let's get in there first or let's get them back.

[02:09:32] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Okay now. I didn't know that the conversation was going here so I didn't brush up on my facts. But the Babi Yar massacre in Ukraine.

[02:09:44] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Mm hmm.

[02:09:46] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I've forgotten how many thousand Jews. How many. Oh 30. That makes more sense. But these people were effectively. Shot. Over the course of days. And. Thrown into a ravine. We know a lot about what happened because there were a few survivors who reported. What had taken place.

[02:10:15] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah. It was very different perpetrators cells as locals that was you know Nazis and there was very much and there was SS and so perpetrators were testified and so of you know people that fell under bodies and locals they just went to watch the show.

[02:10:31] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Yep. Okay. Babi Yar massacre. Responded to. An attack. On the Nazis. By Jews I think that right.

[02:10:48] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Not to my knowledge no. But if you think no because. Maybe there was some kind of false story of. Right. The Nazis had complete control of that territory at the time so it was completely occupied and those those citizens were completely defenseless.

[02:11:16] Dr. Bret Weinstein: And well I agree. I think the story.

[02:11:19] Dr. Jonny Hudson: It means propaganda that was. Right. Friggered. But yeah. Maybe yeah maybe what you're saying does have some truth in it. There was like an explosion somewhere.

[02:11:31] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Exactly an explosion a number of people were

[02:11:34] Dr. Jonny Hudson: killed justify it.

[02:11:36] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Yeah

[02:11:37] Dr. Jonny Hudson: well I mean it's facing you know it's. I don't think it's. I don't know if that's analytically comparable to.

[02:11:48] Dr. Bret Weinstein: No look I'm just using it as a proof of concept my look I am 100 percent on board with Jews blowing up Nazis who have commandeered.

[02:11:59] Dr. Jonny Hudson: In Babi Yar they didn't feel threatened whatsoever.

[02:12:04] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Right no it was read my point is it was it was retribution. For the killing of a handful of Nazis by Jews who I believe were totally justified in doing so but I'm just proof of concept. That the. Genocidal reaction to having been attacked does have if I'm right about the fact of Babi Yar does have. At least one historical precedent. If I'm wrong about the facts of Babi Yar then it doesn't apply and maybe you're right it never happens but. My guess certainly would be especially if you take. My model of lineage against lineage. Violence then you have cycles of. Genocide where one population is powerful and goes after its enemy and the other population becomes powerful and responds you'll have effectively indefinite. Cycles of genocide. Which is exactly what I want the world to recognize is the hazard in the Middle East and it is what I think the world has to recognize we can't be dragged into.

[02:13:17] Dr. Bret Weinstein: We have if anything we have to drag the Middle East out of that pattern. And into a Western understanding you know. Maybe that's what the Abraham Accords are maybe so I guess my point is I think you have these two. Ways of understanding your own society and your competitors. The future belongs entirely to the Western version and at the moment the lineage against lineage violence version is rising and threatening to destroy the West. See your earlier point about invaders on the coast of Britain elsewhere in Europe in the United States. I think the lineage against lineage. Way of being human. Is. Going to take over the globe each of these conflicts is going to spread and there'll be nothing left to save because you can't have lineage against lineage violence in a world of nuclear weapons and directed energy.

[02:14:29] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah I suppose all we all we can do is a little bit to try and divert that eventuality.

[02:14:39] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Yeah although I'm sorry I don't mean to keep ranting that to Jonny but you mentioned. You mentioned Netanyahu in his role I hope I'm not distorting what you said but in his role defending the Jews. And I actually take exception to that I know that you were not speaking precisely but the problem is as a Jew in the diaspora. I feel like I have nothing to do with Benjamin not Netanyahu I can't vote for him I wouldn't vote for him given the opportunity I would see him thrown out of office in an instant. But he keeps speaking as if he is the defender of the Jews not just the Israelis but all of us in the diaspora too. And I feel like he is undermining all of the goodwill that existed towards Jews in the world since World War Two. I don't think I grew up in an era where the fact that I was Jewish didn't really matter from the point of view of how people treated me I'm not saying it was never an issue in any context but it wasn't a big deal.

[02:15:55] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Now it's a huge deal. I didn't ask for that I'm loyal to the West I want to see the West take over Israel for Israel's benefit but I'm now watching all of those of us who understand why the Western way of living is better than bludgeoning each other because we're from different lineages. We're losing our ability to do that because the world is now looking at us as Jews first and I don't know how to escape. I want out I don't want Benjamin Netanyahu speaking for me ever you know I wouldn't let him choose a flavor of ice cream for me he's a madman. But somehow he gets to speak for me and not only that he's dragging me and the entire planet into a conflict not of our making.

[02:16:55] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah I just I'm I don't know how it's crazy that I might be seen as like a Netanyahu defender because I have no real sympathies for the money that I just when I just like think about his task it just blows my mind what what is to me is basically an impossible task. If you view history the world is set against you and maybe there's nothing you can do maybe somebody could have stayed the ship better we'll see if then if if the next guy comes in if he can do a better job. Or all of that remains to be seen.

[02:17:37] Dr. Bret Weinstein: But wait a second though look I don't know you know

[02:17:41] Dr. Jonny Hudson: it's just like can you imagine the task that he has on his hands.

[02:17:46] Dr. Bret Weinstein: I don't think you can imagine it because a reasonable person would not be in his position. In other words if you had woken up on October eighth having conducted. A billion or more dollars towards an enemy that has now massacred more than a thousand of your countrymen. That they were able to do it because you had ignored direct warnings that it was going to happen and left the border unguarded. Would you have stayed in.

[02:18:26] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Absolutely not I would have hoped that would be a mechanism where somebody would just like instantly fire me if I fucked up that badly.

[02:18:35] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Right so what you're now saying is that there's a reason you can't imagine the terrible burden of being Benjamin Netanyahu and it's because no decent person would be in his position they would have resigned they would have apologized. And he didn't. I think that tells you everything you need to know about this guy. He's a monster.

[02:19:00] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Yeah and apparently it's still fifty fifty if he'll remain in power even though the icing top coalition has been invited to. But yet let me also say I think we're bringing this to a close. The. Israel is apartheid people. I think they need to answer why. The. Essentially the second biggest winners of Israel's elections at the moment have been the Arab parties have moved up to 19 percent of the vote. And they may hold sway to who the next. Who the next prime minister is as well. Yeah just just in typical fashion just a little bit of a pro. You know the. You know I've talked about the concentration camp, and now I'm talking about the apartheid thing. But let's let's be logical and realistic in our criticisms of Israel. So it makes sense. And you know it has resonance. Let's not just start throwing throwing around. I'm all up for criticizing Israel in a reasonable way.

[02:20:28] Dr. Jonny Hudson: But when you start saying apartheid concentration camp and genocide as well then then I just stop listening. So why don't you have.

[02:20:40] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Sorry I want to give you the last word and I will. But maybe again maybe my channels are all compromised for whatever reason. But I believe that the concentration camp metaphor for Gaza. Is actually something. That not only has been used by important patriotic Zionist Jews. But. May have started with them. Am I wrong about that.

[02:21:22] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I. I have I don't not really sure. No it must just be like a Western or an Arab invention. I don't know why the patriotic Zionists would invent something like that.

[02:21:45] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well. I don't know either.

[02:21:49] Dr. Jonny Hudson: I don't know. Maybe.

[02:21:55] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Let's put it this way if there's no truth in what I've just said then. I'll gladly apologize for it. It's an honest mistake. I've been misled. But if there is truth in it then it's worth knowing that I would say.

[02:22:14] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Well there's no there's no truth in the comparison. But at all if you're going to make historical comparisons it's a dreadful one that doesn't make any sense and only see only serves to delegitimize whatever you're saying after it. And it's like I've you know when I detailed.

[02:22:33] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well OK. Well let's let's let's explore this then before we close this out. First of all there's a way in which the comparison is destined to be wrong by virtue of scale alone. The actual Nazi concentration camps were tiny compared to Gaza. And therefore the diversity of behavior that you will find in Gaza will inherently be much larger because you can't control a giant population in the same way you can control a tiny population. Yes there will be differences. I would argue and again maybe you can help me understand the detail of this but I think that there is an analogy to be made between the. Let's say the Warsaw ghetto. And Gaza.

[02:23:36] Dr. Jonny Hudson: You know so you know. No no no no no no no. Like 60 percent of the weapons that were used over the sevens were produced in Gaza so they weren't smuggled in and Gaza actually has a border to Egypt as well. So it wasn't like the Nazis allowed like a different way that the Jews could have gotten out. They didn't control you know that quarter of the fence and we don't we don't have a huge amount of money just being pumped into the Jews inside concentration camps and then they're left to do you know should we build infrastructure or should we. You know. And we we don't see the population figures of concentration camps rise by astronomical figures like the you know the population of Gaza. Over the last 70 years as times by nine or 10 and the world population is times by three. So on every meaningful measure. It's. And they've got a border to the sea and quite a nice beach front and they used to use that to attack Israel on October the seventh was also like a sea attack on Zikim beach as well.

[02:24:56] Dr. Jonny Hudson: There's no meaningful comparison to a concentration camp.

[02:25:00] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well the question is. Yeah. All right. I'm persuaded that's not a good comparison. I take it back. Yeah. Well all right. You want to have the last word.

[02:25:20] Dr. Jonny Hudson: Just that this is it's been a fascinating conversation and always. An honor to dig into these most important and serious of topics with somebody as intelligent as you and first and foremost you were made and I don't think I could have this kind of conversation with anybody that wasn't. So thanks mate.

[02:25:47] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Well I'm glad we're still mates. Apparently I haven't lost all of my friends as a result of this conversation. That's good.

[02:25:54] Dr. Jonny Hudson: If anybody takes anything from this conversation then hopefully that's it.

[02:26:00] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Yeah. All right. Great. Well Dr. Jonathan Hudson. It has been I don't want to say a pleasure. This is awful stuff but I am honored to be able to partner with you in exploring these deeply troubling topics. For those who have watched I hope they will detect that this was a discussion had in good faith. I don't think either you nor I have said anything that we did not believe. I'm sure there are mistakes in here. Of course there will have to be because there are places where you and I disagree over some facts. But anyway this is an exploration in the hope of getting to a better place one where genocide is actually unthinkable which you and I would both agree is really the highest and best goal.

[02:27:02] Dr. Jonny Hudson: So OK. Thanks mate.

[02:27:05] Dr. Bret Weinstein: Dr. Hudson thank you and for everybody who watched. Thanks for spending the time.

Credits

Music: “Marble Machine” by Wintergatan. This track can be downloaded for free at wintergatan.net. A free license to use this track in your video can be downloaded at wintergatan.net.

Previous
Previous

Sum Ting Huang: The 352nd Evolutionary Lens with Bret Weinstein and Heather Heying

Next
Next

Consent in the Case of Russell Brand: The 351st Evolutionary Lens w/Bret Weinstein & Heather Heying